Back News Middle East Israel refuses to re-negotiate peace treaty with Egypt

Israel refuses to re-negotiate peace treaty with Egypt

Israel's Minister of Strategic Affairs, Moshe Ya'alon.Israel's Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Strategic Affairs, Moshe Ya'alon, has revealed that Egypt recently requested that Israel re-negotiate the terms of the peace agreement signed between the two states. However, Israel has rejected the request explaining that Egypt must accept Israel's position or risk losing American aid.

Israel Today quoted remarks from Ya'alon in which he stated that Israel would not be carrying out any further major strikes in the Sinai which may give terrorists greater freedom to launch offensives from the territory. He stressed Israeli demands that Egypt find a solution to the problem and step up imposition of their sovereignty in the area explaining Israel's refusal to reconsider the convention's military annex.

He also stressed that if Egypt wanted to deploy additional troops in Gaza, Israel would agree to discuss the matter, however, "it would set a very bad precedent if we agreed to renegotiate our agreements."

Speaking about Egypt's President Mohamed Morsi, Ya'alon stressed that despite his desire to re-negotiate the treaty, he is obliged to abide by it so as not to lose U.S. aid.


Comments

Please respect and abide by our Community Guidelines when leaving comments.


Archived Comments

Comments displayed below are past comments for referencing purposes. They are no longer available for moderation or replies.

+2 # rd
rob 30-10-2012
It can't any clearer than this who controls the American government, when a foriegn country can say who gets American taxpayers money . Americans what a pathetic country of fools.
+1 # Mr.
the_grey_wolfe 23-10-2012
A peace treaty was negotiated 34 years ago. Egypt received all of the Sinai Peninsula returned to its control, along with oil and natural gas discovered by Israel when it controled the Sinai.

What kind of message does it send to the world that a new Egyptian goverment wishes to renege on a treaty already in place?

To me it sends the message that it won't be possible to have confidence in Egypt's level of commitment towards any agreement that it signs with any other country.

Imagine if the Japanese government were to say to the US that they were dissatisfied with the peace treaty of 1945 that ended the Second World War and wanted to re-negotiate...
-1 # Who renegotiates treaties?
Mo 23-10-2012
Treaties are signed so as to be forever, otherwise they are worthless aren't they? As part of the Israel-Egyptian treaty, negotiated and fulfilled in good faith, the Sinai desert and oilfields (discovered by Israel at Abu Rodeis) were handed to Egypt. If Egypt wants to renegotiate then Israel would rightly claim that they go back to square 1 and maybe this time not cede Sinai. In other words renegotiation is nonsensical and has nothing to do with American Aid. You can't selectively renegotiate to your advantage. You can ask I suppose but why would the other party ever agree - by definition it would be to their disadvantage.