Creating new perspectives since 2009

US drops reference to 'Israeli-occupied' Golan Heights in annual rights report

March 13, 2019 at 7:55 pm

Israeli troops are pictured in the Israeli-annexed Golan Heights in Syria on 3 January 2020 [JALAA MAREY/AFP/Getty Images]

The US State Department changed its usual description of the Golan Heights from “Israeli-occupied” to “Israeli-controlled” in an annual global human rights report released on Wednesday, says Reuters.

The move came amid intensified efforts by Israel to win US recognition of its claim to sovereignty over the strategic plateau it captured from Syria in the 1967 Middle East war and effectively annexed in 1981, a step not recognised internationally.

There was no immediate comment from Israeli leaders on the US terminology change, which stopped short of a formal declaration accepting the territorial claim.

READ: US senator vows to push US to recognise Israel’s sovereignty over Golan Heights

The Golan – like the West Bank and Gaza Strip, territories also taken by Israel in the June 1967 conflict – is regarded internationally as occupied under a UN Security Council resolution passed later that year.

On Monday, Republican US Senator Lindsey Graham toured the Golan with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and pledged to lobby the Trump administration to recognise the area as belonging to Israel.

A separate section in the State Department report, on the West Bank and Gaza, did not include the terms “occupied” or under “occupation” in referring to the Palestinian territories.

But a State Department official, commenting on the absence of those words, said: “The policy on the status of the territories has not changed” and the report was focused on human rights issues, not legal terminology.

Palestinians have been concerned about the strength of a long-standing US commitment to the creation of a state of their own in the West Bank and Gaza, a pledge stemming from interim peace deals with Israel signed in the 1990s.

Breaking with a decades-long policy, and drawing Palestinian accusations of pro-Israel bias, President Donald Trump recognised Jerusalem as Israel’s capital in 2017. He moved the US Embassy to the contested holy city from Tel Aviv last year.

READ: American support for Israel at its lowest in a decade

Commenting on the State Department report, Nabil Abu Rudeineh, a spokesman for Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, said new “US labels” for Palestinian lands “will not change the fact that this is occupied territory, in accordance with UNresolutions and international law”.

US officials have said Washington will present a new Israeli-Palestinian peace plan after Israel’s April 9 election.

Netanyahu travels to Washington later this month to address the pro-Israeli lobby AIPAC, and Israeli media reports said he also plans to hold talks with Trump, with the Golan recognition issue on the agenda.

Formal US acceptance of Israel’s territorial claim could bolster Netanyahu’s re-election prospects in a closely contested race as he battles corruption allegations, which he denies.

Hours before the US report was released, Israel accused a suspected Lebanese Hezbollah operative who was previously held in Iraq over the killing of five US military personnel of now setting up a guerrilla network on the Syrian-controlled side of the Golan for cross-border attacks.

US’ $38bn
military aid package for Israel – Cartoon [Sabaaneh/MiddleEastMonitor]