Espanol / English

Middle East Near You

As Turkey’s star wanes, others are on the rise

In 2011, Turkey was seen as an unstoppable regional power and a rising star led by its Justice and Development Party (AKP), but the arrival of the Arab Spring heralded a deep change in the Middle East. Turkey’s prominence began to fade and Iran’s potential appeared to be rising with the progress it is making in nuclear negotiations. Further developments in the region have continued to surprise observers, especially the emergence of the ascendant force that is Daesh/ISIS.

Until the Arab revolts began, many believed that Turkey would enjoy a bright future as a leader in the region under the AKP. Most Arabs were eager to emulate the Turkish model of democracy and economic success. Many politicians established and named their parties after the AKP, and Turkish products and soap operas flooded Arab markets and homes.

With his charisma and rhetoric, Turkish President and former Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan was seen by most frustrated Arabs as a saviour, a leader who cared for his neighbours and had qualities lacking in their own dictators, especially his open opposition to Israeli policies and practices against the Palestinians. Nevertheless, as the Arab Spring continued, a shift began to take place.

Turkey lost territory in Syria, upset the Gulf nations, further strained its lukewarm relations with Iraq, entered into conflict with Israel and finally saw its relations with Egypt deteriorate. And Turkey’s challenges did not stop at its doorstep. With the Gezi Park protests in Istanbul and the 2013 corruption scandals involving a number of AKP ministers, the problems turned out to be domestic as well.

The recent elections in June could be considered the biggest blow suffered by the Turkish AKP since it was founded in 2001; 13 years of single-party rule in Turkey came to an end. While the party had provided Turkey with political stability and economic recovery, the impact of the recent elections on Turkey’s domestic politics and foreign policy will have direct repercussions across the entire region.

Meanwhile, as Turkey’s regional star is setting, others are rising. Iran, for example, is a regional power with considerable potential. Its closest allies in the region — the Assad regime in Syria, Hezbollah in Lebanon and the Houthis in Yemen — have been under tremendous pressure, and their power and leverage has been declining significantly. However, although Iran has suffered a great deal since the advent of the Arab Spring, the nuclear deal reached with the P5+1 nations (the US, UK, Russia, France, China and Germany) will bolster its position over time by the lifting of decades-long sanctions. Furthermore, it will allow Iran to export its oil again, and the re-emergence of such a huge exporter will undoubtedly hurt Russia’s economy. It will also lead eventually to the unfreezing of many more of Iran’s assets; in 2014, for example, the US unfroze $1 billion (€913 million).

If this happens, there is no question that Iran, which could build a network of regional allies and preserve its military capabilities with an immense arsenal of weapons, will become a rising economic power as well. As such, one can expect Iran’s allies, mainly Shia groups, to receive a big boost.

What is more, a remarkable third player has been emerging on the Arab stage: Daesh/ISIS. The group arose from the remnants of dissolved regimes, failed dictatorships and an austere interpretation of Islam, and has imposed and reinforced its presence and influence across the Middle East and North Africa. Its emergence has turned the whole region on its head. Puritanism has swept the Arab world and a new vocabulary – one of apostates, infidels and heretics – has become commonplace. In the blink of an eye, Daesh was able to eliminate borders and take control of large swathes of Iraq and Syria.

The 60-plus members of the US-led anti-Daesh coalition have been unable to stop its expansion and consolidation of its rule. Interestingly, US President Barack Obama announced in July that he believes there is no end in sight to the battle with the group, while stressing that he is opposed to putting any more US boots on the ground.

Daesh/ISIS can be understood as a unique representation of the entangled interests and relations in the region. Through it, some powers aim to weaken Syrian President Bashar Al-Assad’s regime and his closest ally in Lebanon, Hezbollah. Others are eager to use Daesh/ISIS to keep the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) busy and distracted. A third group is interested in it sparking a sectarian conflict that would drag both Sunni and Shia extremists into an endless war, thus “letting the bad guys kill each other”.

US Vice President Joe Biden even accused America’s key allies in the Middle East of allowing the rise of Daesh and supporting it with money and weapons in order to oust the Assad regime. Biden summed up the crux of the issue in his speech at the John F. Kennedy Jr. Forum: “(US allies) were so determined to take down Assad and essentially have a proxy Sunni-Shia war.”

Similarly, US General Wesley Clark stated that, “Daesh got started with funding from our closest allies… to fight to the death against Hezbollah.”

With the current state of affairs, and in light of the recent elections, one can conclude that Turkey’s foreign policy influence and regional leadership role will decline. The AKP, which in the eyes of many Western countries represents a moderate model of Islamic democracy, can no longer form a single-party government and will thus lose the leverage and freedom to execute the kinds of proactive policies it had championed previously in the Middle East. The decline of Turkey will result in the strengthening of other regional forces, notably Iran and Daesh/ISIS. As outlined above, the promising potential of Iran in the region will mean a new role for the country and perhaps a fresh network of Shia allies. Meanwhile, the clout and influence of Daesh – which adheres to a strict Sunni dogma – is growing steadily. Unfortunately, these developments can only lead to only one conclusion: an unavoidable, far-reaching, Sunni-Shia conflict.

This article was first published in East Magazine.

The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Monitor.

Categories
ArticleEurope & RussiaIraqMiddle EastOpinionSyriaTurkey