Creating new perspectives since 2009

The UN and Israel are manufacturing humanitarian narratives

March 19, 2019 at 12:56 pm

Palestinians, in particular the elderly, sick and disabled, come together to call for international efforts to save Gaza from the humanitarian crisis [Mohammed Asad/Middle East Monitor]

Despite the dissonance between Israel and humanitarian aid, there is no lack of propaganda seeking to portray the settler-colonial state as a shining beacon for others to emulate. A forthcoming photo exhibition is now set to be hosted at the UN to showcase, in the words of Israel’s Ambassador Danny Danon, “how far Israel will go to help others in need, regardless of who they are or where they live.” He could and, if he was honest, should have added, “as long as the people concerned are not Palestinians.”

Danon’s statement is telling. Israel will indeed do anything in order to create a false image of benevolence as it seeks to avoid scrutiny of its human rights violations against the Palestinians. Erasing its violence from public view is crucial to maintaining a humanitarian façade; an efficient way to do this is to spring into action wherever and whenever humanitarian emergencies can be milked for political points within the international arena.

In describing the exhibition, Danon declared it to be “another opportunity to show the UN the true and beautiful face of the State of Israel, and its moral values.” His romanticised hyperbole will not alter the fact that Israel was founded upon the terrorism of Zionist militias and the ethnic cleansing of the indigenous Palestinian population. No amount of posturing as a humanitarian example to emulate can compensate for the ongoing Palestinian Nakba.

Nakba journey - Palestinians fleeing during the Nakba in 1948
More than 1 million Palestinians were displaced in 1948
Relive the journey of Nakba refugees

Ironically, given Danon’s gushing and self-congratulatory claims, Israel is mostly skilled at creating the conditions which render a colonised population dependent upon humanitarian aid. The world has seen recently how Israel lobbied successfully for Washington to withhold financial support to the UN Agency which provides humanitarian aid and essential services to the people of occupied Palestine. Similarly, Israel has proven itself to be extremely competent when it comes to enforcing an illegal blockade which, compounded with intermittent military offensives and bombardments in Gaza, prompted the UN to assert that the enclave will become unliveable by next year.

READ: Qatar distributes aid to 55,000 families in Gaza

The exhibition can thus be interpreted as the collaboration of two actors thriving upon humanitarian deprivation. Both the UN and Israel are dependent upon violations of one kind and another; an absence of victims will guarantee their collapse. In terms of obscuring the Palestinian narrative to promote aggressive Israeli diplomacy disguised as humanitarianism, there could be no better partner than the UN and its decades of jeopardising Palestinian lives to accommodate the colonial agenda.

Bringing Israel to the UN is another reason behind the exhibition. The intent, as Danon explained, is to have UN representatives “change their disposition towards Israel” in the General Assembly. No matter what the latest humanitarian endeavour by the Zionist state was a strengthening of diplomatic ties between Israel and Brazil’s right-wing President Jair Bolsonaro, who also favours eliminating indigenous people in their own territories. The exhibition, therefore, has a duplicitous agenda rather than being an opportunity to showcase “humanitarian values”, with the UN playing the part of a willing stooge.

READ: UN urges Israel to lift Palestinian movement limits

Behind Israel’s shameless façade, we see the ongoing colonisation of what remains of Palestinian land, which Israel is intent on completing regardless of whether it finds international support for its violations of international law or not. Whatever the UN may say or do, Israel will continue to act with impunity and contempt for the rest of us. Moreover, if it manages to normalise colonisation by acting within humanitarian parameters in other locations, opposition to Palestine’s complete disappearance as a reality and a cause will dwindle even more within the international community.

US draft resolution at the UN to condemn Palestinian resistance - Cartoon [Arabi 21]

US draft resolution at the UN to condemn Palestinian resistance – Cartoon [Arabi 21]

The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Monitor.