The Metropolitan Police Commissioner, Sir Mark Rowley, has refused to create a specialist team to tackle Islamophobia, a decision that critics say confirms a two-tier approach to protecting minority communities in London, in which Jewish communities get dedicated officers, government funding and political priority while Muslim Londoners facing record levels of hatred are told to rely on general policing.
Rowley made his position clear when he was questioned by Hina Bokhari, a Liberal Democrat member of the London Assembly, which holds the Mayor and the Met to account. In a video, Bokhari said the Met had acknowledged a 77 per cent rise in Islamophobic hate crime this year, and that many Muslims she knows are “genuinely afraid”. She asked whether he would set up a dedicated unit for Muslim communities, like the one already in place for Jewish communities.
Bokhari said Rowley replied that he was “cautious about creating lots of separate units,” arguing that this “fragments our approach.” He said the force had made an exception for Jewish communities “simply” because “the per capita rate is so much higher, and you’ve got the state threats involved. That’s the only reason to do something different.”
Accusing the Met of going back on its commitment, Bokhari said: “When they set up the unit for Jewish communities, they said this would be a blueprint for other communities.” She went on to ask: “So why the double standards? Muslim Londoners deserve to know that their safety is taken seriously, too.”
The Jewish protection unit is only one part of the widely perceived special treatment the state gives to one community. The Metropolitan Police announced a new dedicated Community Protection Team of initially 100 extra officers in May, a day after the then Prime Minister, Keir Starmer, convened leaders from across society in Downing Street to call for action on anti-Semitism.
The team is funded by the Home Office, and it brings together neighbourhood policing, specialist protection and counter-terrorism capabilities in response to sustained threats facing Jewish communities. Rowley had earlier said 300 extra officers were needed. In some weeks the force also arranged an extra 1,000 officer shifts to safeguard the Jewish community, drafting in police from other areas, the Jewish Chronicle reported.
The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) has moved to expedite anti-Semitism cases, and a group of cross-party peers has proposed a team in the CPS dedicated to supporting the prosecution of offences motivated by anti-Semitism.
Muslim communities have no equivalent at any of these levels. That is despite the Met’s own promise, when it launched the Jewish team, that it was intended to provide a blueprint for how policing responds when tensions rise, so that other communities feel equally supported and protected when they face spikes in hate crime or targeted hostility.
Rowley himself said the approach should be sustained “not just for Jewish communities, but as a model that can support other communities across London when facing elevated risk”. Six months on, he has ruled out applying that model to Muslim Londoners.
READ: Police detain Palestine Action supporters outside US Embassy in London
Mosque leaders demand equal treatment
Mohammed Kozbar, chairman of Finsbury Park Mosque in north London, said in a statement seen by MEMO that the mosque was “deeply concerned” by the decision. Many Muslims, he said, face hostility, intimidation, discrimination and hate crimes “simply because of their faith or identity,” and every reported incident represents a person, a family or a community whose sense of safety and belonging has been damaged.
Specialist teams for Jewish communities, Kozbar said, recognise the specific nature of anti-Semitism, and Muslim communities deserve “the same level of recognition, understanding and commitment.” A dedicated Islamophobia team “would not be about creating divisions or competing over resources,” he said, but about making sure Muslim victims get proper support, that Islamophobic incidents are properly understood and recorded, and that the police build trust with Muslim communities.
Without it, he warned, Muslim Londoners will be told that their experiences of hate crime are not given the same priority. “We want to see a police service that protects every community equally,” he said, urging the Met to reconsider.
Record anti-Muslim hatred
The refusal comes as anti-Muslim hatred in the capital reaches unprecedented levels. Data from Tell MAMA, which monitors anti-Muslim incidents, shows 1,031 reports of anti-Muslim hate in the capital from January to the end of June this year. That exceeds the 1,028 reports for the whole of 2023, and follows a record 1,909 last year.
The Met’s own figures show that Islamophobic hate crimes rose from 135 to 179 between April and May, the highest monthly figure since August 2024.
The per capita argument
Rowley rests the special status on the per capita rate. On the Met’s recorded figures, the rate for Jewish Londoners is higher. Census figures show that Muslims make up 14.99 per cent of London’s population and Jews 1.65 per cent, which is around 145,000 Jewish residents against more than 1.3 million Muslims. In May, the Met logged 255 anti-Semitic hate crimes.
Critics, however, question how those figures are produced. The British government formally adopted the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) working definition of anti-Semitism in December 2016. Seven of the 11 illustrative examples that accompany the definition relate to criticism of Israel, and civil liberties groups, academics and others have condemned its adoption by governments as a threat to free speech because it conflates legitimate criticism of Israel with anti-Semitism.
Kenneth Stern, the definition’s lead drafter, has warned that right-wing Jews are weaponising it to suppress criticism of Israel, and that pro-Israel lobby groups use it to silence critics of Zionism.
Sceptics argue that this conflation has inflated reported anti-Semitism by treating opposition to Israel’s conduct, including the Gaza genocide, as anti-Jewish hatred. The rate used to justify one community’s special status, they say, may itself be shaped by a definition built to shield Israel.
READ: An estimated quarter of a million join London march marking three years of Gaza genocide
Surveys in the United States suggest that many Jews blame Israel for the rise in anti-Semitism. A survey of 800 Jewish voters for J Street, the liberal pro-Israel lobby group, carried out between 28 October and 3 November, found that 80 per cent say Israel’s actions in Gaza and the occupied West Bank increase anti-Semitism in the US.
Sixty-six per cent say anti-Semitism is increased by the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) funding a political action committee that runs ads against candidates who criticise Israel. Sixty per cent say Jewish organisations that call harsh criticism of Israel anti-Semitic are exploiting concerns about anti-Semitism to defend unpopular Israeli policies.
A separate survey by the Mellman Group for the Jewish Electorate Institute in September found that 56 per cent of American Jews believe Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s actions have directly increased anti-Semitism and anti-Israel sentiment in the US.
A hierarchy of racism
Muslim leaders and anti-racism campaigners have long accused the British establishment of operating a “hierarchy of racism”, in which anti-Semitism is treated as a national priority while Islamophobia and other forms of racism are pushed down the list.
The charge was given official weight in 2022 by the Forde Report, an inquiry into the Labour Party commissioned by Starmer. It cited concerns that the attention paid to the surge in anti-Semitism cases meant the party was “operating a hierarchy of racism or of discrimination with other forms of racism and discrimination ignored”.
Martin Forde KC, the barrister who led the inquiry, later said the party had not fully engaged with the charge that anti-Black racism and Islamophobia were not being taken as seriously as anti-Semitism.
Critics say the same pattern runs through government. Since 2019, ministers have appointed an Independent Adviser on Anti-Semitism, while Muslims waited almost a decade after the IHRA adoption for any official definition of the hatred they face.
When it finally came in March, the government dropped the word “Islamophobia” and opted for “anti-Muslim hostility”. The Muslim Council of Britain (MCB), the country’s largest Muslim umbrella body, said it was “unable to endorse” the definition. Academics told Hyphen that focusing on hostility rather than racism puts understandings of Islamophobia out of kilter with similar religiously rooted racisms such as anti-Semitism, and risks generating a hierarchy of racism.
The gap is just as stark in funding. In July, the government announced its “largest-ever investment” of more than £250 million (around $333 million) to strengthen security for Britain’s Jewish communities, but it declined to say whether it would increase funding to protect Muslim communities, The New Arab reported.
READ: Palestine is a testing ground for a new type of fascism, artists told at London event






