clear

Creating new perspectives since 2009

Between Mandela and Morsi: Imran Khan and the Sadism of the Pakistani State

November 17, 2026 at 3:18 pm

Former Pakistan’s Prime Minister Imran Khan [ARIF ALI/AFP via Getty Images]

Listen
0:00 / 0:00
1.0x
Ready

Pakistan’s rulers imprisoned Imran Khan to destroy him politically. Instead, they have manufactured a revolutionary symbol whose stature now exceeds anything they can control. Having failed to break his political will, they appear determined to break his body. The man they fear releasing may now die in their custody.

On 16th November, Khan’s lawyer, Salman Safdar, released a devastating appeal to Pakistan’s highest judges. The seventy-four-year-old former prime minister describes twenty-two hours of daily solitary confinement, severe restrictions on family and legal contact, an 85 percent loss of vision in his right eye, and blood pressure reaching 193. Doctors, he says, have warned of brain haemorrhage, cardiac arrest and existing heart damage. His wife, Bushra Bibi, reportedly risks permanent visual impairment without further surgery.

Pakistan’s authorities dispute his allegations and maintain that he has received medical attention. But Khan says the Supreme Court’s 18th August order requiring treatment at Shifa International Hospital and restored family contact remains unimplemented.

Apparently, Pakistan’s mighty military establishment considers an independent ophthalmologist more dangerous than an invading army.

Yet the most chilling allegation concerns neither Khan’s eyesight nor his heart. He says prison personnel are forbidden even to answer his greetings or respond when he recites Qur’anic verses.

READ: More Nobel prizes for Trump? Pakistan’s ruling clique from flattery to fallout

If substantiated, this is cruelty elevated into administrative policy. Solitary confinement isolates a prisoner; enforced silence seeks to erase his humanity. It is punishment designed not merely to incarcerate but to humiliate, psychologically crush and destroy.

And it reveals the extraordinary insecurity of Pakistan’s rulers.

Field Marshal Asim Munir commands one of the world’s largest military establishments. The Sharif and Bhutto-Zardari dynasties enjoy the privileges of civilian power beneath its protective canopy. Together, they command prisons, police, intelligence agencies, ministries and the machinery of political repression.

Yet one ageing prisoner terrifies this entire architecture. Because Khan is no ordinary political opponent.

No Pakistani politician of comparable stature has combined his national following with such extraordinary international recognition. Before politics, Khan was a World Cup-winning cricket legend and celebrated philanthropist. His admirers extend beyond PTI, beyond Pakistan, beyond
Muslims and even into India, where sporting respect crosses some of the region’s fiercest ideological divisions. International cricketing legends have publicly demanded humane treatment for him.

For Pakistanis at home and across the diaspora, he represents resistance to entrenched corruption and military tutelage. For admirers among Kashmiris and Palestinians, his outspoken advocacy of their rights carries particular resonance. His opposition to American drone warfare,
Islamophobia, Israeli policies toward Palestinians and externally dictated Muslim politics made him an unusually visible challenger to Western imperial priorities and the regional political arrangements protecting Israel.

His significance is therefore not merely electoral. He challenges the domestic hierarchy of generals, dynastic politicians and comprador elites while articulating a vision of Muslim sovereignty that refuses automatic submission to Washington and its regional allies.

This is why his imprisonment has become an international moral scandal. And why the comparison with Nelson Mandela and Mohamed Morsi is so alarming. Mandela and Morsi were radically different political figures. Their movements, constituencies and achievements cannot be equated. But their imprisonment illuminates two consequences of authoritarian repression.

Mandela represents the prisoner whom incarceration could not defeat. Morsi represents the prisoner whom incarceration helped destroy.

Twenty-seven years behind bars transformed Mandela from a resistance leader into an international symbol of liberation. His jailers controlled his physical existence but ultimately failed to suppress the political movement he embodied. He emerged to witness the collapse of
apartheid.

Morsi experienced the opposite trajectory. Egypt’s first democratically elected president was overthrown by the military in 2013, imprisoned amid longstanding concerns about his confinement and medical treatment, and died during a court appearance in 2019. He never emerged free. His death left grave questions about the responsibilities of those holding
him. Khan now stands between these possibilities.

Like Mandela, his imprisonment has enlarged rather than diminished him. Every prosecution, restriction and attempt at political erasure has reinforced his image as the man Pakistan’s military establishment cannot defeat through ordinary political competition.

Like Morsi, however, his reported physical deterioration raises the horrifying possibility that the state may preside over the death of the very prisoner it has failed to silence.

There is another crucial distinction. Morsi’s Muslim Brotherhood confronted a profoundly divided Egyptian society. Khan possesses an exceptionally broad following, reinforced by a sporting and philanthropic legacy that predates his political career and reaches audiences far beyond Pakistan.

Pakistan’s rulers have already created Mandela’s political paradox. They now risk producing Morsi’s fatal outcome.

The historical irony is savage. A reformist-nationalist politician associated with welfare, anti-corruption and political independence has been transformed by relentless persecution into the foremost symbol of resistance to Pakistan’s military-dominated order.

The Sharifs and Bhutto-Zardaris have contributed enthusiastically to this transformation. Heirs to dynasties themselves scarred by military repression, they now benefit from the exclusion of their strongest opponent while delivering solemn lectures about democracy.

Apparently, democracy is sacred until the electorate threatens to exercise it.

The hypocrisy extends beyond Pakistan. Western governments and Muslim intellectual institutions that thunder against arbitrary detention, occupation and authoritarianism elsewhere have too often treated Khan’s persecution with conspicuous caution.

The nationality of the jailer does not change the rights of the prisoner. Nor does the political convenience of the jailer excuse the silence of those who profess universal principles.

READ: Trump went to Iran for regime change. Iran delivered it in Washington

But this is no longer merely an argument about geopolitics. It is a question of life and death. Pakistan knows that eliminating a leader does not eliminate the political memory surrounding that leader. Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto’s execution and Benazir Bhutto’s assassination became defining chapters in the country’s history.

Khan’s fate threatens an even more combustible reckoning. If he survives, his jailers may confront a politically strengthened opponent. If he dies amid unresolved allegations of medical neglect, they risk leaving behind an accusation that will haunt Pakistan’s political establishment for generations.

Mandela survived imprisonment and witnessed the defeat of his oppressors. Morsi died in custody, leaving his jailers to answer for the circumstances of his death.

Khan is asking for neither power nor privilege. He is demanding medical treatment, basic human dignity and the opportunity to remain alive long enough to obtain justice. Pakistan’s rulers have already helped turn him into a Mandela-like symbol of resistance. They must not turn him into Pakistan’s Morsi.

Because if Khan dies, history will indict not only his jailers, but also the UN, human rights organisations, Pakistani and Muslim leaders, and progressive activists who had the power to speak, the influence to intervene, and the opportunity to act — but chose silence. Those who preached justice but practiced silence, who condemned oppression elsewhere but accommodated it here, will share the moral burden of a tragedy they had the chance to prevent.

The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Monitor.