It does not come from a border officer or in a stamped letter. It comes as a terse email, barely signed, to a man in the middle of packing for a journey. He reads it once, then again, scarcely able to believe it: his electronic travel authorisation has been cancelled because his presence is “not conducive to the public good”. No charge, no hearing, no meaningful appeal. His only offence is to have said about Gaza what the whole world has seen with its own eyes.
I now hear versions of this story almost daily. The names and the passports change but the message does not. In early June, the Home Office cancelled the travel permits of the American media figure Hasan Piker and his uncle, the political commentator Cenk Uygur, over their remarks on Israel. Weeks ago, the same email reached the Swedish academic Andreas Malm, a week before he was due to speak at a Palestine event in London, and the Palestinian-American activist Moath Hamzeh, vice-chair of a UK-registered charity supporting Palestinians, shortly before his flight. And across the Atlantic last month, the former mayor of Barcelona, Ada Colau, was refused a US travel permit; those close to her say her interview dwelt almost entirely on her support for Palestine and her role in the flotilla seeking to break the siege of Gaza.
Israel pioneered the practice. It routinely revokes the entry permits of foreign volunteers – many of them Jewish – who come to stand alongside farmers and schoolchildren in West Bank villages and shield them from settler attacks.
The notice is always the same: “a change of circumstances in your case”, and nothing more.
These are not undocumented refugees or obscure figures, but prominent academics, journalists and politicians who hold some of the world’s most respected passports; passports that offered no protection once their holders drew close to Palestine.
READ: Trump administration bars prominent Spanish politician from Puerto Rico after Gaza flotilla activism
A ladder of repression
Each new case deepens my conviction that the pressure on solidarity with just causes, Palestine foremost among them, has entered a new phase. Barring speakers is, in fact, the lowest rung of the ladder. Above it lie suspended social media accounts and throttled reach, then closed bank accounts for charities and individuals, then arrests and investigations over a post or a placard, and at the top, the proscription of entire organisations, with support for them made a criminal offence.
Those of us who work in public life feel this daily in the care we now take over every word, in the questions young people ask about what is and is not permitted, and in the anxiety of parents whenever their children leave for a vigil or a march.
The question, then, is simple: will these measures restore Israel’s reputation, or arrest its steep decline in Western esteem?
Why the bans will backfire
I believe the answer is that these measures are likely to achieve the very opposite of what their architects intend.
First, Israel’s standing did not collapse because an academic gave a talk or a journalist posted a tweet. It collapsed because people saw Gaza; entire neighbourhoods razed, children beneath the rubble, and starvation wielded as a weapon. Silencing the messenger erases none of those images from the minds of millions, restores none of the dead and rebuilds not a single home.
Second, the ban itself becomes the story. An event that might have drawn a hundred people becomes national news, and the excluded speaker reaches a far larger audience than if they had simply been allowed to speak. In case after case, each door closed on an activist opens a window for thousands asking why.
Third, Western publics hold free expression dear.
When British or European citizens see their governments excluding nationals of friendly states for their opinions, rather than for any genuine security threat, they begin to ask questions they had never thought to ask. Why is a foreign state’s image being protected at the expense of our own liberties? And who decides what we may hear?
READ: UN rapporteurs decry rising attacks on human rights defenders in occupied West Bank
The illusion of balance
I know the stock reply to any such complaint: the authorities are not targeting one side, but barring “extremists” from both. Occasionally a pro-Israel activist is excluded, and the case is circulated endlessly as proof of even-handedness. A simple tally tells the story: a single case on one side against dozens on the other. It is a scale with one pan laden and the other empty, held up before the cameras and declared balanced.
Yet even were the scale genuinely level, the essential problem stands; bans resolve nothing. One may dislike a speaker’s manner, the sharpness of their language or some of what they say – that is one’s right. But the answer to words is words, and the answer to an opinion is a better argument and not closed doors and revoked permits. A society confident in itself, does not fear a public meeting nor tremble at a lecture.
A cause that cannot be deported
This is why the circle of solidarity is widening rather than shrinking. Civil liberties organisations, human rights lawyers, journalists and academics defending university freedom have joined it, including some who disagree with the excluded activists but defend their right to be heard.
Nor do I know a single activist whose resolve has been weakened. On the contrary, these measures have convinced us that our work matters. Why else would anyone strive so hard to silence us? No one bothers to suppress a voice that nobody hears. When ministries, agencies and lobby groups mobilise to keep one academic off a panel, they bear unwitting testimony that words can still unsettle them, and that the Palestinian narrative has escaped the narrow corner to which it was confined for decades.
Such measures expose Israel, and those who support and sustain it, far more than they protect them. They announce to the world that its crimes can no longer be defended with facts and argument, and must instead be guarded by bans, blocks and pressure. Whoever must silence the other side has quietly conceded the debate.
An email may stop a man at an airport gate, but it cannot stop an idea from crossing borders. The Palestinian cause was never built on a handful of names that can be struck from a passenger list. It rests on a right that does not lapse with time, a memory no departmental decision can erase, and a human conscience that grows wider by the day.
Each time an activist opens their inbox to find that email, another message goes out with it; one that nobody wrote, yet the whole world can read: this is an occupation that cannot bear to be seen in the light of truth. Let them close as many doors as they wish; the light still comes in through the cracks.
OPINION: Abdul El-Sayed: ‘Trump can just call me senator now’
The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Monitor.







