clear

Creating new perspectives since 2009

Oxford event hears case for apology for Britain over Palestine

November 18, 2026 at 1:15 pm

A ‘Liberated Zone’ banner is seen inside a pro-Palestine encampment set up by students in front of the Oxford University Museum of Natural History on May 6, 2024 [Laurel Chor/Getty Images]

Lawyers and historians behind a 400-page legal petition arguing that Britain acted unlawfully during its rule of Palestine from 1917 to 1948 have renewed their call for a government apology, more than a year after the document was submitted without a response.

Speaking at Trinity College, Oxford, yesterday, a panel of historian Professor Avi Shlaim, barrister Danny Friedman KC, international lawyer Dr Victor Kattan and anthropologist Professor Dawn Chatty set out the case made in the Britain Owes Palestine petition. Dr James McDougall, a historian of colonialism and decolonisation at Trinity College, chaired the event. It took place in the month of the 109th anniversary of the Balfour Declaration, the 1917 letter in which Britain pledged support for a Jewish national home in Palestine.

The renewed call comes weeks after Prime Minister Andy Burnham said he was open to a formal apology for Britain’s role in the transatlantic slave trade. Defending the move, Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband said: “I think it’s the opposite of weak. I think fragile, weak countries can’t face up to their past.”

The petition’s authors say they are not weighing one history against another. Their argument is that the principle of acknowledging past wrongs should not be applied selectively. Miliband has said the UK cannot remain “silent or passive” in the face of Palestinian suffering, they point out, yet on Britain’s own record in Palestine the government has stayed silent. As MEMO noted on the petition’s first anniversary, London has shifted its position on the occupation but not on its own history.

The petition was submitted to the government in September 2025 on behalf of 14 Palestinians. They are led by Palestinian philanthropist Munib Al Masri, who was shot by British soldiers at the age of 13. Barristers Ben Emmerson KC, a former UN special rapporteur on counter-terrorism and human rights, and Danny Friedman KC prepared the petition with Kattan, Shlaim and Professor John Quigley, an American scholar of international law. 

In the months since the since petition was submitted, 45 MPs and peers and 27 Members of the Scottish Parliament (MSPs) have backed it, along with public figures including singer Paloma Faith, comedian Alexei Sayle and green energy entrepreneur Dale Vince.

The petition documents abuses committed while Britain controlled Palestine under the mandate system. Abuses include torture, arbitrary detention, extrajudicial killings and the mass demolition of homes. It argues that Britain changed the legal, political and demographic character of the territory without the authority to do so. It did this by occupying Palestine in 1917, going back on its promises to the Arab peoples and setting up the Mandate in 1922. 

READ: ‘Propping up apartheid’: UK failing legal duties on Palestine, new briefing warns

When the UK issued the Balfour Declaration on 2 November 1917, the authors say, Britain abandoned the commitments to Arab independence, including in Palestine, that it had made in the Hussein-McMahon correspondence. These were letters exchanged in 1915 and 1916 between Sharif Hussein of Mecca and Sir Henry McMahon, Britain’s High Commissioner in Egypt. In their place, Britain made an incompatible promise of a Jewish national home in a country whose population was overwhelmingly Palestinian Arab.

As an occupying power, Britain was bound by the Hague Regulations, the international rules governing military occupation, to preserve the territory’s existing institutions. Instead, the petition argues, it unlawfully altered the status quo to carry out the Declaration. Palestinians have long demanded that Britain apologise for the Balfour Declaration, and critics have accused successive governments of selective memory about its legacy.

The petition asks the government to consider its evidence, search for records not yet released to the National Archives and respond fully and publicly. It also calls on the government to acknowledge Britain’s wrongful acts, issue an official apology and investigate in good faith what forms of accountability, reparation and investment in the Palestinian people and the State of Palestine are appropriate. The authors say reparation is not just about financial compensation. It could also include policy change, education initiatives, support for self-determination and diplomatic support for Palestinian rights grounded in international law.

Shlaim, Emeritus Professor of International Relations at the University of Oxford, who discussed the campaign with MEMO in September, said: “The history of the British Mandate is the history of how Britain took Palestine from the Palestinians. Yet it is barely taught in British schools, and no British prime minister of either party has ever acknowledged that role, let alone apologised for it. It is time for Britain to confront its past.”

Kattan, Smuts Visiting Fellow at the University of Cambridge and Assistant Professor in Public International Law at the University of Nottingham, said: “The petitioners are owed an answer, yet fourteen months after our petition was delivered, we are still waiting. The Government has said that confronting the past is a sign of strength, rather than weakness. We agree, and the passage of time is no bar to acknowledging historical wrongs.”

Chatty, Emeritus Professor of Anthropology and Forced Migration at the University of Oxford and former director of its Refugee Studies Centre, said: “The mass displacement of Palestinians in 1948 is not simply history. For generations of refugees, it has never ended, and Gaza today shows how devastating its consequences remain.

“Britain played a central role in Palestinian dispossession, yet refugees’ experiences remain largely absent from how this history is told here. Acknowledging that responsibility must mean recognising those whose lives are still shaped by it, including in how we teach this history.”

READ: Oxford Union votes that Israel poses ‘greater threat’ to regional stability than Iran