clear

Creating new perspectives since 2009

Republicans bent their faith on gay marriage. On Islam, Israel keeps them from bending

November 19, 2026 at 2:11 pm

U.S. President Donald Trump delivers remarks at the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool in Washington, D.C., on November 2, 2026. The event is held one day before the US midterm elections. Trump seeks to maintain Republican control of both chambers of Congress as voters prepare to head to the polls. [Mehmet Eser – Anadolu Agency]

Listen
0:00 / 0:00
1.0x
Ready

On 3 November, Democrats won every statewide office on the ballot in Texas, their first statewide victories since 1994, and Gina Hinojosa unseated Republican Governor Greg Abbott. Nationally, NBC News exit polling showed 86 per cent of Muslim voters backing Democrats and 11 per cent backing Republicans. An exit survey by the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR), the largest Muslim civil rights organisation in the US, and its political arm, CAIR Action, found a similar divide. Respondents named the Gaza genocide, the US-Israeli war on Iran, the economy and rising Islamophobia as their top concerns.

Tech billionaire Elon Musk spent nearly half a billion dollars backing Republicans in the midterms, around $224 million of it in Texas. His America PAC sent Muslim voters campaign material showing a woman in a hijab waving the American flag. Next to her were James Talarico, the Democrat now Texas’s senator-elect, and New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani, under the slogan “It’s either they/them [non-binary pronouns] or Us.” Musk’s own companies, meanwhile, promote their LGBTQ-friendly policies.

These door hangers were left on Muslim homes days before the election [Faith Coalition for Justice/Instagram]

These door hangers were left on Muslim homes days before the election [Faith Coalition for Justice/Instagram]

The Republican Party’s record on same-sex marriage shows how its religious commitments bend when its political interests change.

In 2016, the Republican Party platform condemned the Supreme Court’s legalisation of same-sex marriage. In 2022, 39 House Republicans and 12 Republican senators joined Democrats to pass the Respect for Marriage Act, which requires federal recognition of same-sex marriages. In 2024, under Trump’s direction, the language defining marriage as between a man and a woman disappeared from the party platform.

In January 2025, the Senate confirmed Trump’s choice for Treasury Secretary, Scott Bessent, an openly gay conservative who is married to John Freeman. The Treasury Secretary is fifth in line to the presidency, which makes Bessent the highest-ranking openly gay official in American history.

Republicans did keep some promises to their religious base by banning gender-affirming care for minors. But how wise is it to support Republicans while some in the party wage what they call a crusade against Muslims?

Opposition to same-sex marriage once mobilised evangelical voters. When it lost its political value, Republicans moved on to transgender issues. After this year’s elections, some within the party are calling for a rethink of its strategy.

The campaign against Islam serves the occupation of Palestine

The Republican Party is a coalition of business interests, conservative activists and Christian nationalists, and its religious commitments bend to the needs of that coalition.

In September 2025, Drop Site News revealed that Israel’s Foreign Ministry had hired Stagwell Global, a US marketing firm, to improve Israel’s image abroad. The leaked research found that messages invoking fears of “Radical Islam” and “Jihadism”, alongside Israel’s support for women’s and gay rights, raised support for Israel by an average of more than 20 points across the countries surveyed.

Some Republican hostility to Islam is rooted in nativism and Christian nationalism. Some of it also serves to shield Israel’s occupation of Palestine from Muslim advocacy.

In September, the Republican majority on the Texas State Board of Education (SBOE), which sets the state’s curriculum standards, voted 8-4 to approve new history standards. These teach early Islam through the Prophet Muhammad’s (PBUH) “brutal military campaigns against Jewish and Christian tribes” and the taking of female “harem slaves”. The same standards teach that Israel was established in 1948 “in the ancestral homeland of the Jews”, effectively erasing Palestine.

Laurie Cardoza-Moore, president of the pro-Israel evangelical group Proclaiming Justice to the Nations, asked why CAIR had been allowed to address the SBOE at all. She cited Abbott’s November 2025 order declaring CAIR a terrorist organisation. “How can we let terrorists decide our children’s curriculum?” she asked. Her group says the board later adopted several of its recommendations.

Audrey Young, the board member who introduced the Israel amendment, lost her seat in November. Democrats will hold an 8-7 majority on the board once the new members take office. The standards do not reach classrooms until 2030, which leaves time for the new majority to reverse them if Muslims organise.

Republican officials have also used gay rights to attack Muslim-majority countries. In 2019, the Trump administration launched a campaign to decriminalise homosexuality worldwide. It was led by Richard Grenell, a prominent gay Republican who was then US ambassador to Germany and is now Trump’s envoy for special missions. The office of then-Vice President Mike Pence told NBC News he backed the effort. It pointed to a speech in which Pence said Iran “executes gay people” and “openly advocates the destruction of the State of Israel”.

The party that once campaigned against same-sex marriage on religious grounds now has room for a gay Treasury Secretary and a gay special envoy. Its religious objections gave way when the politics changed. Its hostility to Muslims who advocate for Palestine has not, because that hostility serves a different purpose.

The courts cannot replace political power

As Republicans promised to turn anti-Muslim rhetoric into anti-Muslim policy, some Muslim Republicans said they trusted the courts to protect their religious and civic rights. That confidence grew in March, when US District Judge Alfred Bennett ruled for Muslim parents and Islamic schools challenging their exclusion from Texas’s private school voucher programme.

Florida Governor Ron DeSantis followed Abbott’s lead and declared CAIR a terrorist organisation by executive order in December 2025. In March, US District Judge Mark E Walker blocked the order. The state legislature responded by giving DeSantis that power in law. On 4 November, Chief Judge Allen C Winsor of the same court declined to block the new designation, and CAIR shut down its Florida operations the next day. CAIR is appealing.

In Texas, outgoing Attorney General Ken Paxton dropped the state’s lawsuit against CAIR on 16 November. Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa had already pledged to remove CAIR from the state’s terrorist list.

Muslims should not be blind party loyalists

Democrats have their own anti-Muslim and anti-Palestinian bigotry. In 2024, the Biden-Harris administration kept arming and enabling Israel’s genocide of Palestinians while asking Muslim Americans for their votes.

This year in Michigan, Abdul El-Sayed became the first Muslim elected to the US Senate. He won despite anti-Muslim bigotry from both Republicans and Democrats whose priorities include protecting Israeli interests. Democrats court Muslim voters but resist Muslim leaders who challenge the party on Israel. Muslim voters know this: in the CAIR exit survey, a third of respondents said neither party was more responsive to Muslim concerns.

In 2024, many Muslims used their votes to tell Democrats that supporting Israel’s genocide of Palestinians would cost them. In 2026, Muslims showed Republicans that brazenly attacking Islam and turning anti-Muslim bigotry into state policy would cost them votes too. Donald Trump won 21 per cent of the Muslim vote in CAIR’s 2024 exit poll. This year, Republicans won just 6 per cent.

Punishing a party at the ballot box does not build power on its own. Power is built between elections, especially at local level: at city council meetings and in state government. It is also built in primaries, where Muslim turnout is often far lower than in general elections. Primaries decide who gets onto the ballot, long before most voters show up.

CAIR Action Texas early voting numbers. Final results will be updated once the Texas Secretary of State releases final data

CAIR Action Texas early voting numbers. Final results will be updated once the Texas Secretary of State releases final data

Providence, Rhode Island, shows what local organising can do. The Providence for Palestine Coalition, a group of local advocacy organisations, put a divestment measure on the November ballot. It passed with 75 per cent of the vote, showing how local electoral organising can take Palestine advocacy beyond protest and into policy.

Muslim Americans have raised millions for pro-Palestine candidates for federal office. We can put some of that political and financial strength into legal defence funds and into local civic work that holds state and local officials to account.

Fewer than 600 votes flipped control of Texas’s State Board of Education. That is one mosque’s Friday congregation.

The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Monitor.