Over the weekend Indian authorities bulldozed several homes belonging to Muslims in the northern state of Uttar Pradesh (UP). The homeowners were alleged to have taken part in organised protests on Friday in response to inflammatory remarks about the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) made by the now ousted spokesperson for the country's ruling-Hindu hardline BJP party. It is the latest provocation against India's sizeable Muslim population, following a high-court decision in March in the southern Karnataka state to ban women wearing the hijab in schools and colleges.
The Indian government was forced to distance itself from the comments amid a diplomatic storm between New Delhi and several Muslim majority countries, including Iran and strategic partners in the Gulf. However, on the ground the damage had already been done, as popular anger gave way to demonstrations by India's significant but marginalised Muslim minority.
Among those whose houses were razed to the ground was a young Muslim activist Afreen Fatima who is the daughter of Javed Mohammad, an activist himself associated with the Welfare Party of India, a political party launched by the Muslim organisation, Jamaat-e Islami Hind.
Tactics from Israel, now in India https://t.co/tT5Xl6Qvos
— Ishaan Tharoor (@ishaantharoor) June 12, 2022
Indian police accuse her father of being one of the main organisers of the protests which erupted in the UP city of Prayagraj (formerly Allahabad but renamed in 2018 in line with Hindu nationalist sentiments) while many ended peacefully, some soon turned violent and tensions arose between Muslims and Hindus, spreading to other parts of the country. Hundreds have since been arrested and police forces shot dead at least two Muslim protestors in the eastern city of Ranchi in a bid to disperse the protestors.
The decision to demolish homes of people associated with the protests was ordered by the chief minister of UP, Yogi Adityanath, who justified the actions claiming the properties were illegal establishments. Since the order, three demolitions have taken place in two days – the properties of two people were razed after they were accused of stone throwing. The firebrand Hindu monk and politician who belongs to Prime Minister Narendra Modi's BJP party has since vowed to continue with "bulldozer action".
A Muslim home in India is a Palestinian home under Israel! No to Israeli Apartheid and Zionism! No to Indian Apartheid, Hindutva and Casteism! No to Islamophobia! #existenceisresistance #afreenfatima #ApartheidIsrael #ApartheidIndiahttps://t.co/6xPUNWxBT6 pic.twitter.com/aR7lNCEIC5
— Iskander Abbasi (@IskanderAbbasi) June 13, 2022
As footage of the demolitions fast became viral on social media, observers and critics were quick to point out the stark parallels with long-standing policies implemented by Israeli occupation forces against the homes of Palestinians, ordinary citizens, protestors and resistance members alike. Just last year it was estimated that Israeli forces demolished 937 structures, displacing nearly 1,200 people.
In which country, under which law can you destroy the homes of those who participate in protests against insult to their faith?
This happens only in Israel or in India…..
Like they are living under stone age pagan ritualistic society devoid of all morals & humanity.
— Zaid Hamid (@ZaidZamanHamid) June 11, 2022
Senior Congress leader Shashi Tharoor reacting to Afreen Fatima's house being demolished yesterday questioned whether the local government had exempted itself from the country's Constitution. The Thiruvananthapuram MP tweeted: "Due process of law is fundamental to democracy. Under what law and following what process has this been done? Has UP exempted itself from the Constitution of India?"
While a worrying development, razing people's homes are expected as Israel and India forged strong ties in recent years, with both countries governed by religious-nationalist ideologies (Zionism and Hindutva, respectively) with both facing accusations of apartheid policies, in fact these charges date back as far as 2002, when Modi was chief minister for Gujarat, when the state witnessed some of the worst anti-Muslim violence in decades. These comparisons are all the more compelling when both countries pride themselves on their supposed trademarked democratic values – Israel "the only democracy in the Middle East" and India being "the largest democracy in the world".
It has become evident that Modi's government is taking a leaf out of Israel's book when it comes to the practise of destroying homes, ironically citing "illegal settlements" and "security concerns". India's recent disproportionate activities over mere stone-throwing in two cases, is also reflective of similar Israeli actions. Only last week, an Israeli lawmaker drafted a draft law seeking to double the punishment for throwing stones to four years and last year the Israeli military's rules of engagement were revised to formally permit the opening of fire against Palestinians who throw stones, even as they flee.
Even the case of bulldozing illegal settlements raises fundamental rights issues and concerns over due process. The Indian Express noted yesterday in a report that "In many cases, notices are issued but the demolition is timed with a protest and a particular section is targeted giving the subject no time to appeal."
Former Allahabad High Court Chief Justice Govind Mathur was quoted in the report as saying: "This is totally illegal. Even if you assume for a moment that the construction was illegal, which by the way is how crores of Indians live, it is impermissible that you demolish a house on a Sunday when the residents are in custody. It is not a technical issue but a question of rule of law."
The recent razing of houses belonging to India's Muslim minority is a dangerous precedent and illustrative of the direction the country is heading, following Israel's lead. However, the practise itself is not unprecedented, as in April authorities in New Delhi bulldozed a number of "illegal" Muslim-owned businesses, requiring the Supreme Court to step in and halt further destruction. Following this incident, Pranay Somayajula, an advocacy and outreach coordinator for the US-based Hindus for Human Rights, opined last month that "The fact that bulldozers have cropped up in both India and Israel as a chilling symbol of state repression is no coincidence."
India's continued adherence and emulation of Israel's apartheid policies against a significant and politically-inconvenient minority, is further proof that neither country is the secular, value-based democracy it claims to be.
The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Monitor.