clear

Creating new perspectives since 2009

Iran-France tensions escalate over Charlie Hebdo cartoons row

January 12, 2023 at 2:17 pm

Iranians protest against defamatory cartoons depicting ​​​​​​​Iran’s supreme leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei published by French satirical weekly Charlie Hebdo, outside the French embassy in Iran’s capital Tehran on January 8, 2023. ​​​​​​​ [Fatemeh Bahrami – Anadolu Agency]

Tensions between Iran and France are on the boil over the publication of caricatures of the Iranian Supreme Leader, with the country’s top General warning of revenge, Anadolu News Agency reports.

French satirical magazine, Charlie Hebdo, published a series of caricatures depicting Ayatollah Ali Khamenei in its special issue last week, which Iranian authorities deemed “insulting” to the top political and religious figure.

Many Iranian officials, including the President, Foreign Minister, top military commanders and senior parliamentarians, have issued statements criticising the magazine and the French government.

There have also been a series of demonstrations in front of the French Embassy in Tehran in recent days, amid growing calls to review diplomatic ties with France.

READ: Iran summons France envoy over ‘insulting’ cartoons 

In the most scathing reaction to the publication of the cartoons, which were part of a competition announced by the magazine last month, the chief of Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), on Tuesday, said Muslims will “sooner or later” exact revenge against Charlie Hebdo.

Maj. Gen. Hossein Salami, speaking at an event in south-eastern Iran’s Zahedan city, asked the owners of Charlie Hebdo magazine to “look into the fate of Salman Rushdie”.

Rushdie was attacked during an event in New York on August 12 last year, almost 33 years after Iran’s then-Supreme Leader Ayatollah Khomeini issued a fatwa (decree) against him for his controversial novel, “The Satanic Verses”, published in 1988.

The IRGC Commander said the French satirical magazine, which has previously been involved in controversy over the publication of cartoons of Islam’s Prophet Muhammad, made a “big mistake” by publishing Khamenei’s caricatures, and will see the revenge.

“Do not play with (the sentiments of) Muslims,” Salami said. “Salman Rushdie insulted the Quran and the Holy Prophet of Islam 30 years ago and went into hiding.”

“After several years, a young Muslim man bravely took revenge on Salman Rushdie and no one could save him,” he added.

The IRGC General, however, did not explain the nature of “revenge” against the French magazine.

Indecent act

The cartoons featuring Ayatollah Khamenei were published days before the 8th anniversary of a terrorist attack on Charlie Hebdo headquarters in January 2015, which killed 17 people.

Iranian Foreign Minister, Hossein Amir-Abdollahian, last week accused France of choosing “the wrong path” by allowing the publication of cartoons mocking the country’s top figure.

“The insulting and indecent act of a French publication in publishing cartoons against the religious and political authority will not go without a decisive and effective response,” he wrote on Twitter.

The Foreign Ministry also announced a decision to review France’s cultural activities in Iran and the closure of the decades-old French research centre as the “first step”.

French Ambassador to Tehran, Nicolas Roche, was summoned to the Ministry last Wednesday and told that Iran does not tolerate insults to its sanctities.

“France has no right to justify insults to sanctities of other countries and Muslim nations under the pretext of freedom of expression,” Ministry spokesman, Nasser Kanaani, said in a statement.

In response to Iran’s decision to shut down the French Institute for Research, which operates under the French Embassy in Tehran, Foreign Ministry spokeswoman, Anne-Claire Legendre, said in a statement last week that it was “clearly regrettable if confirmed”.

READ: Iran shuts French Institute amid row over Charlie Hebdo cartoons 

Charlie Hebdo, for its part, vowed to publish more cartoons of Iranian leaders, dismissing recent threats from Iran’s military officials.

 IRGC designation

Amid heightened tensions, the French Foreign Ministry, on Tuesday, said it was considering the idea that the European Union label Iran’s IRGC as a terrorist organisation.

It came a day after German Foreign Minister, Annalena Baerbock, on Monday said a new round of sanctions against Iran would not be enough, backing the move to designate the IRGC.

“Listing the Revolutionary Guard as a terrorist organisation is politically important and makes sense,” she wrote on Twitter, while also referring to legal obstacles.

Paris, which has been reluctant to endorse the move so far, appears to be changing its stance amid rising tensions with Tehran over the Charlie Hebdo caricatures controversy and the arrest of some French nationals in Iran on charges of espionage in recent months.

Earlier this month, Iran’s judiciary issued indictments against two more French nationals arrested on charges of “espionage, gathering, and collusion” against the country’s internal security, taking the total number of French detainees in Iran to seven, as per French officials.

“Given the continuation of this repression, France is working with its European partners on new sanctions’ measures, without excluding any,” Legendre said on the designation of IRGC.

Iran has previously warned that designating the IRGC as a terrorist organisation would be a “completely illegal” move as it is the official military branch of the Iranian government.

READ: Lebanon’s Hezbollah calls on France to punish satirical magazine over Khamenei cartoons