When Pakistani Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif addressed COP31 in Antalya on 12th Nov, his request sounded modest: finance that does not deepen the debt of vulnerable countries. The numbers show why it is anything but.
The UN Environment Programme estimates that developing countries need about $305 billion a year by 2035 to adapt to climate change, or roughly $420 billion once inflation is counted. International public adaptation finance reached $28.2 billion to $31.7 billion in 2024, only $1 billion more than the year before. Even if governments meet the COP30 aim of at least tripling it by 2035, UNEP calculates that would cover just 20 percent to 29 percent of needs. And the aim is softer than it sounds: the decision only calls for efforts to triple, with no baseline year or dollar figure.
The direction of travel is worse. A Carbon Brief analysis published 11th Nov. found that new public climate-finance pledges for developing countries have fallen by more than 70 percent. Pledges are not disbursements, and some spending may continue without fresh announcements. But sea walls, drainage systems and drought-resistant farming take years to build, and governments cannot plan them on money that may not arrive.
This is the gap Baku was meant to close. At COP29, developed countries agreed to take the lead in mobilizing at least $300 billion a year by 2035, within a wider goal of $1.3 trillion a year from all sources. Many vulnerable countries judged that insufficient. COP31 has inherited the dispute, along with unresolved fights over fossil fuels.
The quality of the money matters as much as the quantity. The OECD reports that developed countries provided and mobilized $136.7 billion in 2024, exceeding the old $100 billion goal for the third straight year. That deserves recognition. But loans made up 67 percent of public climate finance, and grants only 29 percent. Support for low-income countries was $9.6 billion in 2024, still below its 2022 peak of $11.1 billion.
Debt can work for some projects. A solar plant earns revenue that repays the loan. A flood barrier, a drainage canal or a coastal defense usually protects lives without producing a cash return. Asking indebted governments to borrow for those projects creates a trap: disasters weaken public finances, reconstruction adds spending, and repayments crowd out schools, hospitals and the next round of prevention.
OPINION: Turkiye can turn climate promises into action at COP31
Pakistan knows the trap well. The 2022 floods affected 33 million people and caused more than $30 billion in damages and economic losses. They exposed weak infrastructure and preparedness, and showed how a single season of rain can erase years of development gains. The problem reaches well beyond Pakistan. Island states face rising seas and stronger storms, African economies face drought and unstable rainfall, and across South and Southeast Asia floods, heat and water stress threaten livelihoods. In each case, climate vulnerability becomes financial vulnerability when governments lack the fiscal room to prepare before disaster strikes.
Climate justice is not a case for unlimited aid without accountability.
Developing countries must manage money transparently, plan adaptation credibly and build institutions that can spend it well. Funds that are misallocated, delayed by red tape or diverted from the people they are meant for betray the communities they are supposed to protect.
Wealthy countries face real constraints too: official development assistance is projected to shrink again, and budgets are stretched by defense and domestic demands. Private capital, development banks and new financial tools all have a legitimate role.
The question is which money should go where. Grants and deeply concessional support should come first for adaptation that protects lives and public infrastructure but earns little. Loans and private investment fit projects with credible revenue and manageable repayment risk. Debt-for-climate swaps, well-designed guarantees and targeted concessional finance can stretch scarce public money without loading vulnerable countries with obligations they cannot carry.
Reporting should also tell the truth. A package should not be judged by its headline value alone. Reports should separate grants, loans and mobilized private money, and show how concessional, accessible and genuinely new each is. COP31 can move beyond announcements toward a framework with predictable multi-year commitments, simpler access to climate funds, more support for locally designed adaptation programs and stronger tracking of how money is spent.
None of this replaces cutting emissions.
No amount of adaptation finance will be enough if warming keeps accelerating, and major emitters must speed up their shift to cleaner energy while recognising that countries start from different places.
The test in Antalya is not the size of the next headline number. It is whether a country facing the next flood can invest in resilience beforehand without mortgaging its recovery. Climate finance should break the cycle of disaster and debt, not finance it.
OPINION: Beyond Makkah: Defence pacts must become economic networks
The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Monitor.






