On 29th October, it was announced that Russian authorities practically shut down Novaya Gazeta, described as “Russia’s last free newspaper”. It was, rightfully, met with condemnation in Western media, “as press freedom faces its darkest hour”, to quote the European Federation of Journalists.
It just so happened that on the day before the closing of Novaya Gazeta, the military dictatorship of al-Sisi in Egypt forced editor-in-chief Lina Atallah – after multiple fabricated indictments against her without her possibility of defense – to pay massive fines and to permanently close the only free newspaper in Egypt, Mada Masr. All others have been banned by now.
Unlike the case of Novaya Gazeta, the closing of Mada Masr was no “darkest hour”. In fact, it was barely reported in major papers, with only marginal exceptions, which were forgotten just as fast. There were certainly no op-eds in the major press, since they were busy writing odes to Novaya Gazeta.
The case of suppression and silencing of Lina Atallah is just one out of many by dictator general al-Sisi.
For instance, poet Ahmed Douma, who was imprisoned for ten years, was recently put in isolation for having published an article about the issue of political prisoners in Egypt. Film producer Omar Salah Marei was kidnapped by government forces and is indefinitely detained without trial. Journalist Hamdi Al Zaeem has been imprisoned without trial for ten years. Recently, government forces kidnapped six journalists, tortured them in high-security prisons, barred them from speaking to lawyers, and forced them to “admit” to terrorism charges (a standard tactic of the regime).
READ: Egypt’s government refuses to free political prisoners
These are, as one letter to the US by human rights organizations noted, just drops in the ocean of Egypt’s “merciless crackdown on the press, political opposition, and civil society”. “Systematic torture is a state policy” in Egypt, informed a study. A joint report by multiple human rights groups warned that “torture [is] so widespread it may amount to a crime against humanity” – likewise “routine practices of enforced disappearance and unending pretrial detention”. “Enforced disappearance”, wrote 16 civil rights organizations, “is a systematic and widespread practice of the security agencies. Citizens are abducted and tortured in National Security premises, often to coerce confessions”.
Crucially, the ample reports and studies about this topic are virtually unknown to a Western audience. That is especially shocking, since the West – America and the EU – is the dictatorship’s principal sponsor.
General al-Sisi, this more than a decade-old “reliable partner” (quoting the EU), has been lavishly funded and armed with tens of billions of dollars by Europe and the United States. The US fell “deeply in love” with him, the West’s “favorite dictator” (quoting Trump).
For example, human rights organisations have long documented “the role of EU-manufactured arms systems in internal repression and human rights violations in Egypt … EU Member States which have been exporting weapons and surveillance technology, including dual-use technology”, and “further aggravates the use of lethal and disproportionate force against civilians, mass arbitrary arrests”.
We should not selectively criticise enemies (Russia) when they violate freedom of the press, while avoiding criticising and trying to defend freedom of the press when violated in countries over which we have direct influence and responsibility.
Otherwise, the moral value of our condemnations of Russia would have the same moral value and integrity as some Belarusian commissar condemning the West for the eradication of freedom of the press in Egypt, but saying not a word about freedom of the press in the allied Russia.
Defend Lina Atallah and freedom of the press in Egypt, too.
OPINION: Banning Palestine activists from the West will not save Israel’s image
The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Monitor.








