US Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed has rejected the argument that his criticism of Israel fuels fears of anti-Semitism, saying that feeling uncomfortable is not the same as being unsafe and that silencing criticism of the genocide in Gaza to spare someone discomfort would mean treating Palestinian lives as mattering less.
El-Sayed, a Michigan Democrat, became the first Muslim elected to the US Senate earlier this month. Speaking at The Atlantic’s forum yesterday, El-Sayed was asked how he would respond to someone who said: “Well, I find that your critiques of Israel fuel my fears of anti-Semitism.”
He replied: “I’m sorry for your fear. Obviously, I don’t want to do anything that drives your fear. At the end of the day, there’s a difference between safety or lack of safety and comfort. If what I’m saying is making you uncomfortable, you should be uncomfortable with injustice perpetrated on other people. You should be uncomfortable with that”.
Rejecting the use of discomfort among Israel’s supporters as grounds for silencing criticism of the apartheid state, El-Sayed added: “Addressing the safety question and the discomfort question are two different things, because if it is your sense of your discomfort and/or fear that has to keep me quiet while I watch 70,000 people get killed, their homes annihilated, their hospitals destroyed… and I can’t critique that, then I think what you’re telling me is that their humanity matters less than yours. And I’m not going to be okay with that.”
Q: What is your response to someone who comes up to you and says, “Well, I find that your critiques of Israel fuel my fears of antisemitism.”
El-Sayed: I’m sorry for your fear. Obviously, I don’t want to do anything that drives your fear. At the end of the day, there’s a difference between safety or lack of safety and comfort. If what I’m saying is making you uncomfortable, you should be uncomfortable with injustice perpetrated on other people. You should be uncomfortable with that.
Addressing the safety question and the discomfort question are two different things, because if it is your sense of your discomfort and/or fear that has to keep me quiet while I watch 70,000 people get killed, their homes annihilated, their hospitals destroyed… and I can’t critique that, then I think what you’re telling me is that their humanity matters less than yours. And I’m not going to be okay with that.
— Acyn (@Acyn) November 17, 2026
El-Sayed’s argument echoes one that critics of Israel have long made: that claims of discomfort are being used to shut down debate about Israel’s conduct in Gaza. They also point to a double standard.
When Muslims and other minority groups say they are uncomfortable with hostile rhetoric about their faith or communities, their concerns are often dismissed, and they are told to toughen up. Those who raise such concerns are frequently mocked as “snowflakes” by the same commentators who treat discomfort over criticism of Israel as a threat to safety.
Peter Beinart, the Jewish American journalist and editor-at-large of Jewish Currents, wrote on X that the distinction El-Sayed drew is a familiar one: “His point about the difference between discomfort and lack of safety has long been a staple of conservative and centrist discourse. In fact, El-Sayed makes it more gently than folks to his right. He doesn’t mock ‘snowflakes.’ What’s new here isn’t his logic. It’s applying that logic to the debate about Israel.”
His point about the difference between discomfort and lack of safety has long been a staple of conservative and centrist discourse. In fact, El-Sayed makes it more gently than folks to his right. He doesn’t mock “snowflakes.” What’s new here isn’t his logic. It’s applying that logic to the debate about Israel.
— Peter Beinart (@PeterBeinart) November 18, 2026
El-Sayed used the same appearance to repeat his charge that the US was complicit in Gaza, saying: “We aided, armed, and abetted a genocide.” He also said Israel ought to be a country that upholds equal rights for all of its citizens and does not identify itself with a culture or a faith, and he described Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu as a war criminal who, along with those who aided and abetted his actions, should be held accountable.
“I believe that Israel ought to be a country that upholds equal rights for all of its citizens, does not identify itself with a culture or a faith, and that dignifies the rights of those citizens to live free under its laws. That’s, again, the question of peace, dignity, and self-determination”, said El-Sayed.
His remarks come as pro-Israel groups continue to attack him over his record on Israel. Senator Bernie Sanders said the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC), the main pro-Israel lobby group in the US, spent $39 million trying to defeat him. Its super PAC had already spent more than $30 million against him in the Democratic primary. This week, a US Jewish community leader warned that the Democratic leadership’s embrace of El-Sayed raised “real concerns”. El-Sayed has consistently rejected the charge, saying “My commitment to Jewish safety is the same as my commitment to the safety of my own kids.” Fox News
Since his election, El-Sayed has also backed calls to end US military aid to Israel, including remarks by President Donald Trump.
READ: Abdul El-Sayed backs Trump’s call to cut Israel aid, says he is willing to work with president







