clear

Creating new perspectives since 2009

Two years after the ICC warrant, Israel’s road back to international respect runs through a fair trial for Netanyahu

November 21, 2026 at 11:59 am

A large group of Jewish and Muslim demonstrators carrying banners and Palestinian flags march from Bryant Park toward the United Nations headquarters to protest the policies of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and US President Donald Trump regarding the war in Gaza in New York, United States, on September 24, 2026. [Waleed Zein – Anadolu Agency]

Listen
0:00 / 0:00
1.0x
Ready

On 21st November 2024, the International Criminal Court issued an arrest warrant for Benjamin Netanyahu over alleged war crimes and crimes against humanity in Gaza. Two years later, Israel’s political leaders are bargaining over the 61 votes needed to form a government. Among the concessions that might secure a majority, one should be unthinkable: any promise to shield Netanyahu from having to answer for decisions he took as prime minister.

In October, I argued in these pages that Israel’s next government must end Gaza’s catastrophe. The election has since raised a question for Israelis themselves. Who will establish responsibility for the decisions taken in their name? Israel is not Netanyahu. Its citizens should not carry collective blame for one leader’s conduct. Yet when a government spends its diplomatic capital defending that leader from scrutiny, it invites the world to identify an entire country with his decisions.

The new Knesset has already shown the limits of Netanyahu’s authority. On 17th November, his opponents elected a new Speaker while he remained prime minister. President Isaac Herzog has asked Gadi Eisenkot to form a government. Eisenkot’s bloc holds 48 seats, Netanyahu’s holds 53, and Arab-led parties won the remaining 19.

Arab citizens whose votes Netanyahu sought to discredit may yet have a decisive say in who governs Israel. Their representatives are entitled to ask any prospective prime minister whether the price of a coalition deal will include impunity.

The damage to Israel’s standing is measurable. In a Pew Research Center survey published in June, a median of 67 per cent of adults across 36 countries held an unfavourable view of Israel. Opinion had deteriorated in 13 of the 24 countries for which a comparison with the previous year was possible. In Germany, where the historical commitment to Israel runs particularly deep, 83 per cent expressed little or no confidence in Netanyahu’s handling of world affairs. Israeli diplomats will have to answer for that loss of confidence long after he leaves office.

READ: Israel’s next government must end Gaza’s catastrophe

Hamas bears responsibility for what happened on 7th October. Netanyahu bears political responsibility for how his government chose to wage the war that followed. A Palestinian parent who lost a child in Gaza has as much right to ask who made the decisions that led to that death as an Israeli parent bereaved on 7th October. Both deserve answers that can withstand scrutiny.

Consider one allegation in the ICC warrant. The judges found reasonable grounds to believe that Netanyahu bore criminal responsibility for the use of starvation as a method of warfare. For a family that went hungry in Gaza, the questions are painfully concrete. Who decided how much food could enter? What did ministers know about the consequences? What did they do when those consequences became clear? Cabinet records, military directives and witness testimony could help answer those questions. Israel should preserve that evidence and cooperate with the court. A fair prosecution also requires that Netanyahu be able to challenge the evidence and that the judges be free to acquit him if it falls short.

As Middle East Monitor reported on 20th November, emails from 2024 obtained by Drop Site News show that an Israeli diplomat offered Iowa Attorney General Brenna Bird a fully funded trip to Israel. Weeks later, he asked her to invoke Iowa’s anti-boycott law against Türkiye. At the Israeli government’s request, Bird also joined other state attorneys general in a statement opposing the ICC prosecutor’s action against Israeli officials. There is something absurd about looking to Des Moines for an answer to the evidence in The Hague. What could a declaration signed in Iowa tell a Palestinian family about who decided whether food would reach Gaza?

Opening the records to independent scrutiny would do more for Israel’s credibility than any number of declarations.

Netanyahu’s political judgement has also had consequences far beyond Gaza. In February, Israel and the United States attacked Iran. Iran retaliated, and shipping through the Strait of Hormuz slowed almost to a halt. In November, as regional governments tried to avert renewed all-out war, the Associated Press reported that Netanyahu was pressing Washington for another joint air campaign. Washington bears responsibility for its decision to join the attacks, and Tehran for its attacks on shipping. Netanyahu must answer for Israel’s part in starting that confrontation and explain what another round of strikes could achieve at a cost others are already paying.

Some of that cost reaches families through the price of bread. Before the war, roughly a fifth of the oil consumed worldwide and as much as 30 per cent of internationally traded fertilisers passed through Hormuz. A farmer who buys fertiliser before planting, diesel at harvest and transport to market can feel the same disruption three times before a loaf reaches the table. That farmer had no vote in Israel’s election. He has every reason to question the judgement of leaders calling for another war.

Palestinians need humanitarian access now and a credible path to a state alongside Israel on the basis of the 1967 borders.

Israelis need leaders who understand that their children’s security depends on Palestinian children being able to grow up in safety. Both peoples have a stake in a public record of what happened in Gaza, tested in court, where witnesses can be heard and the accused can mount a defence.

Two years after the warrant, Israel’s next government has an opportunity to make a promise that would carry weight well beyond its borders. It will preserve the records, cooperate with independent judges and accept their verdict. No bargain for a sixty-first vote is worth more to Israel’s future than keeping that promise.

The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Monitor.