Creating new perspectives since 2009

If there is any justice in this world, Israel’s criminal politicians and generals will be held to account

October 11, 2023 at 9:59 am

Israeli soldiers patrol near burned and destroyed houses after Palestinian resistance fighters infiltrated a kibbutz near Gaza on 10 October 2023 in Kfar Aza, Israel [Amir Levy/Getty Images]

It hasn’t taken long after the Palestinian guerrilla attack on the Israeli settlements surrounding the Gaza Strip for confessions to surface announcing Israel’s failure, who was responsible for it, and what Hamas achieved from Operation Al-Aqsa Flood.

The attack was launched a day after the 50th anniversary of Israel’s defeat in the 1973 October/Yom Kippur War. While that was a real existential threat to Israel, what’s happening now is proving that Israel was mistaken about Hamas, for which the operation is a victory of sorts. Fighters from the movement’s armed wing took control of Israeli settlements for hours, with an unprecedented casualty toll among soldiers and settlers alike.

Israelis know that the time to hold their security services to account for this will surely come. The images coming out of the settlements were unimaginable for Israelis who were left wondering where their army was. They relived the shock and disappointment of fifty years ago.

READ: Extraordinary escalation in conflict has caused concern on both sides of Jerusalem

Palestinian resistance fighters have gained experience and are better trained than before. Their tactics are more effective after earlier failures to operate in the vicinity of Israeli military bases and settlements. Cumulative expertise was employed to such an extent that Israelis inevitably feel that another deterrence factor has collapsed. All the bombs and destruction cast upon Gaza in retribution will not change that fact.

Hamas depended on the element of surprise. In the end, the guerrillas’ breakthrough was surprisingly easy. Many had reached settlements before the security breach was even discovered, despite the technology deployed along the nominal border fence. Israeli reports have confirmed that the Palestinian resistance groups had developed significant surveillance techniques to monitor the fence for any weak spots.

Early reports suggested that some soldiers turned and fled

OPINION: Could Bin Salman emerge as the saviour of Palestine?

The Israeli security forces were confused for a long time; it took a while for soldiers to realise what was going on. They had to guess the number of resistance fighters and consider the possibility that settlers had been taken hostage in their homes, and that soldiers were being held hostage in their bases. Early reports suggested that some soldiers turned and fled.

The settlement blocs and the agricultural land around them were supposed to be protected by the Israel Defence Forces 24/7. That doesn’t appear to have been the case. The surveillance posts and watchtowers were apparently left unmanned for a crucial period.

Despite the settlements being well fortified and guarded using the latest technology, the attacks proved that this was not enough. Crucially, the Palestinian guerrillas knew how to exploit the obvious Israeli routines and arrogance. The army will no doubt learn from this; its air of invincibility on the ground in face-to-face fighting has been shattered; its mainly conscript soldiers were terrified.

Many Israelis hold the extreme far-right coalition government led by Benjamin Netanyahu and the army hierarchy responsible for this security lapse and the bloody price paid by settlers and soldiers. It has been their worst nightmare come true.

READ: Israel’s total siege of Gaza ‘prohibited’ by international law, UN says

The ongoing bombardment of Gaza’s largely civilian population is both cowardly and illegal under international law; it is collective punishment of the worst kind. As is the total siege of the territory. This is not a “war” between two states. It is an asymmetric conflict between lightly armed guerrillas and a nuclear-armed regional power, with civilians caught in the middle. The result will, inevitably, mean hundreds, perhaps thousands of Palestinian civilians killed and wounded.

It will also see the shattering once and for all of the myth of the IDF’s “purity of arms” and the claim that it is the “most moral army” in the world. Israeli troops and their officers — and the politicians who govern them — may now have to think twice before travelling abroad; if there is any justice at all in this world, arrest warrants for the International Criminal Court will be waiting for them.

The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Monitor.