Creating new perspectives since 2009

Qatar’s decision to quit OPEC raises doubts about the future of the oil cartel

December 6, 2018 at 11:19 am

Saad Sherida Al-Kaabi, Qatari Minister of State for Energy Affairs, speaks during a press conference in the capital Doha on 3 December 2018 [ANNE LEVASSEUR/AFP/Getty Images]

The decision by the State of Qatar to leave the Organisation of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) by January 2019 has raised eyebrows and set off speculation as to the extent of tensions and discord within the 15-member intergovernmental organisation.

The dominant analysis centres on Qatar’s spat with Saudi Arabia and the Qataris’ desire to abandon an organisation which many feel is overly influenced by the Saudis. Notwithstanding official Qatari denials that their decision to leave OPEC is linked to the Saudi-led embargo, nonetheless the Saudis are likely to interpret the move as a further sign of Qatar’s growing independence in the Arabian Gulf region.

Beyond the immediate political effect, Qatar’s decision raises difficult questions about the future of OPEC. There will be fears in Riyadh about a sudden meltdown, especially in light of speculation that Iraq may be the next country to leave the organisation.

Scare mongering aside, OPEC is faced with difficult economic and political choices going forward. As the economic and political value of oil diminishes in the very long term so does the relevance of an organisation like OPEC. In the short to mid-term however, Saudi Arabia’s established behaviour of weaponising oil to advance its foreign policy may no longer be sustainable.

Minister: Iran will not discuss OPEC quota while under US sanctions 

A symbolic blow

Qatar’s departure from OPEC will not destabilise this well-established inter-governmental organisation. For a start Qatar is a relatively minor oil exporter whose exports in the past couple of years have averaged at around 500,000 barrels per day.

Nor has Qatar ever been a big political player in OPEC with the ability to influence major decisions and strategic policy. In the past 58 years, since OPEC’s foundation in 1960, the big players have been Saudi Arabia, Iran, Iraq and to a lesser extent Venezuela.

Notwithstanding Qatar’s minor role in OPEC, the announced departure is a blow to the organisation at a time of heightened uncertainty. The biggest uncertainty surrounds the extent to which petroleum products will continue to be of high value to global transportation systems.

Whilst past predictions of the depletion of oil reserves have turned out to be vastly exaggerated, nevertheless the basic fact is that as energy demands increase three-fold over the course of this century the quest to find alternatives to fossil fuels will intensify.

One of OPEC’s jobs is to keep fossil fuels, and specifically petroleum, at the top of the energy agenda. Hitherto, it has had a relatively easy ride on this front as there has been little determined and concerted effort to identify alternatives to relatively cheap fossil fuels.

But the balance of power – in respect of fossil fuels and potential alternatives – is shifting and it is doubtful if OPEC has either the innovative attitude, strategic foresight and the underlying institutional coherence to act as a singularly effective lobby for petroleum.

READ: Qatar withdraws from OPEC, ends nearly six decades of membership 

The Saudi spoiler

Qatar’s declared reason for leaving the oil producers’ cartel is that it wants to focus more on its gas industry. But Qatar’s Energy Affairs Minister, Saad Sherida Al-Kaabi, left little to the imagination when he said that: “We are not saying we are going to get out of the oil business but it is controlled by an organisation managed by a country.”

From Riyadh’s point of view, the disrespect implied by this obvious swipe at Saudi dominance is compounded by fears over the future trajectory of Qatar’s energy policy. Whilst Doha has relatively low oil reserves, by contrast it is the world’s biggest exporter of liquified natural gas (LNG).

Doha’s stated aim of focussing more on the LNG sector is bad news for Riyadh inasmuch as it hints at greater alignment with Saudi Arabia’s nemesis Iran. Qatar and Iran jointly own the world’s largest natural gas field in the Arabian Gulf. Known as South Pars to the Iranians and North Dome to the Qataris, the natural gas field is central to both countries’ energy policy.

Furthermore, Qatar’s decision to leave OPEC coincides with tension and uncertainty over Iran’s position within the cartel. Faced with a belligerent US administration whose stated goal is to reduce Iranian oil exports to “zero”, the Islamic Republic is more determined than ever to maintain its position in the international oil markets.

On the eve of the latest OPEC meeting today in Vienna, the Iranian Petroleum Minister, Bijan Zangeneh, has made it clear that Iran will not reduce daily output as long as it labours under US sanctions. This is a barely concealed swipe at Saudi Arabia’s policy of cutting production to boost prices.

The price of oil has dropped by 30 per cent since October and Saudi Arabia appears determined to prevent a further drop even at the risk of offending the Kingdom’s enthusiastic ally Donald Trump who has consistently called for low oil prices.

More broadly, Saudi Arabia’s dominant role within OPEC poses potentially existential issues for the oil producers’ cartel primarily because of Riyadh’s consistent vulnerability to pressure by non-OPEC powers. The Kingdom’s historic manipulation by the US to steer OPEC towards a direction consistent with US interests is well known.

More recently Saudi Arabia has been working with non-OPEC oil producer Russia to determine the strategic direction of the international oil markets independent of OPEC. This underhand behaviour is not only inimical to OPEC’s integrity but calls into question its continued existence.

The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Monitor.