Creating new perspectives since 2009

France: Egypt human rights record worse now than under Mubarak

January 28, 2019 at 2:12 am

French President Emmanuel Macron and Egyptian President Abdel Fattah Al-Sisi in Paris, France on 24 October 2018 [Chesnot/Getty Images)

French President Emmanuel Macron said on Sunday human rights in Egypt were perceived as worse now than under former strongman Hosni Mubarak, who was toppled by protests in 2011, Reuters reports.

His comments marked a hardening after he said in 2017 he would not “lecture” President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi over civil liberties, which activists say are being eroded.

“I think current policies are perceived by intellectuals and Egypt’s civil society as tougher than under the Mubarak regime,” Macron told reporters on the sidelines of a trip to Egypt.

Mubarak, a former air force commander, was jailed for conspiring to kill demonstrators who ended his three-decade rule, but he was freed on appeal in 2017.

“I can’t see how you can pretend to ensure long-term stability in this country, which was at the heart of the Arab Spring and showed its taste for freedom, and think you can continue to harden beyond what’s acceptable or justified for security reasons,” Macron added.

READ: 8 Egypt human rights groups reject calls to amend constitution

“I think that’s becoming paradoxical and harmful for Egypt itself.”

Non-governmental organisations are pressuring Macron to be firm with the Egyptian president, who in April secured a second term, shoring up his position as a power-broker in the region.

Macron said he would be more outspoken during the three-day trip, which began on Sunday, and would also mention individual cases in private. He was to meet Sisi on Monday.

Sisi’s critics accuse him of cracking down on all dissent, but supporters say tough measures are needed to stabilise Egypt, rocked by years of unrest after the fall of Mubarak.

In an interview earlier this month, Sisi denied that Egypt was holding political prisoners, though one rights group estimates the number at 60,000.

READ: 8 years after uprising, Egyptians say freedoms have eroded

In October 2017, Macron gave Sisi, who was visiting Paris, a list of activists he believed could be released from prison.

On Sunday, he said only two of them had been freed, which he considered “unsatisfactory.”

“I will at the same time have a confidential dialogue on individual cases and speak out more distinctly, as well as have symbolic exchanges because I think that’s in the interest of President Sisi and Egypt’s stability,” Macron said.

In Egypt, we’re not only talking about political opponents who are being imprisoned but opponents who are part of the traditional democratic sphere and are not threatening the regime. Journalists, homosexuals, women and men of conviction.