Portuguese / Spanish / English

Why are Lebanon's politicians fighting the Beirut port blast probe?

A general view of Beirut Blast explosion site at the Port of Beirut on December 03, 2021 in Beirut, Lebanon [Contigo/Getty Images]
A general view of Beirut Blast explosion site at the Port of Beirut on December 03, 2021 in Beirut, Lebanon [Contigo/Getty Images]

An investigation into last year's Beirut blast is set to resume after a court rejected the last of several lawsuits that had led the probe to be suspended for more than a month. The investigation into the blast, one of the biggest non-nuclear explosions ever recorded, has faced pushback from a political system where impunity has become entrenched since the end of the 1975-1990 civil war.

Here's what you need to know about the standoff:

WHAT IS THE JUDGE INVESTIGATING?

The explosion was caused by chemicals left at the port for more than six years and which killed more than 215 people, injured thousands, and devastated swathes of Beirut.

Judge Tarek Bitar, 47, wants to interrogate several senior politicians and security officials.

High-level security and government officials "foresaw the significant threat to life … and tacitly accepted the risk of deaths occurring," Human Rights Watch has said.

Bitar's efforts have become a rallying cry for many Lebanese against decades of unchecked corruption and mismanagement.

WHO DOES THE JUDGE WANT TO QUESTION?

Some very powerful people.

The most prominent include former Finance Minister, Ali Hassan Khalil, who is the right-hand-man of Parliament Speaker, Nabih Berri, and an ally of the Iran-backed Hezbollah, and Major General, Abbas Ibrahim, head of Lebanon's General Security.

The judge has also sought to question Hassan Diab, an academic who was Prime minister at the time of the blast.

OPINION: Lebanon may be independent, but it still depends on too many other states

Many of them could face prison time if convicted of negligence or causing deaths, although Lebanon has almost no track record of holding to account people in top positions.

All deny wrongdoing.

HOW ARE BITAR'S EFFORTS BEING STYMIED?

All of the current and former officials Bitar has sought to question as suspects have resisted, arguing they have immunity or that he lacks authority to prosecute them.

This resistance to his actions has played out in the courts, in political life, and on the streets.

Lebanon is one long tale of disaster and crisis - Cartoon [Sabaaneh/MiddleEastMonitor]

Lebanon is one long tale of disaster and crisis – Cartoon [Sabaaneh/MiddleEastMonitor]

Suspects have swamped courts with more than two dozen legal cases seeking Bitar's removal over alleged bias and "grave mistakes", leading to several suspensions of the probe.

The ex-ministers say any cases against them should be heard by a special court for presidents and ministers.

That court has never held a single official accountable, and it would pass control of the probe to ruling parties in parliament, likely burying hopes of accountability.

Sectarian sensitivities have been brought into play.

The move against Diab, for example, prompted objections from Sunni Muslim political and religious leaders, who said it was an attempt to target the position of Prime Minister, which is reserved for a Sunni in Lebanon's sectarian political system.

WHY DOES HEZBOLLAH CARE?

Bitar has not charged any known members of Hezbollah, the Shia Muslim group that has powerful political influence and a heavily armed militia. But the judge's actions, including his attempts to question powerful figures allied to Hezbollah as suspects, have prompted the group to accuse him of bias.

In September, a senior Hezbollah official sent him a message warning that the group would "uproot" him.

Hezbollah and its allies have pushed for Bitar's removal via the executive branch, sparking a row that has paralyzed the government.

READ: Protestors block roads amid economic meltdown

Together with its allies, Hezbollah called for an anti-Bitar protest in October, which escalated into deadly violence.

Hezbollah has accused the United States, which lists the group as a terrorist organisation, of meddling in the probe. The US ambassador has denied this.

Hezbollah dismissed accusations made at the time of the blast that it had an arms warehouse at the port and says it had nothing to do with the explosion. Its adversaries have long accused the group of controlling the port – something it also denies.

WHAT'S AT STAKE?

Any hope of accountability.

For advocates of reform, the tussle over the probe is part of a wider struggle about the rule of law and bringing to account officials for corruption and bad governance responsible for other catastrophes, too, including Lebanon's financial meltdown.

Critics say the elite are using their influence to block any attempt to set a precedent of holding officials to account and want to bury any scrutiny of the port's management, which is a microcosm of the sectarian system which parcels out public resources to serve the interests of major players, not the State.

Beirut's already strained ties with Western governments, whose help could prove vital in lifting Lebanon out of its economic crisis, may suffer further if the probe is torpedoed.

Lebanon will rise up from its ashes - Cartoon [Sabaaneh/MiddleEastMonitor]

Lebanon will rise up from its ashes – Cartoon [Sabaaneh/MiddleEastMonitor]

Categories
LebanonMiddle EastNews
Show Comments
Show Comments