Creating new perspectives since 2009

UK accused of creating migrants into scapegoats over Channel Crossings

March 30, 2023 at 4:27 pm

Border Force escorted 85 migrants back to Dover after they were picked up by the English Channel [Stuart Brock – Anadolu Agency]

The British government has been widely reported over its controversial asylum policies to tackle the mounting number of English Channel crossings by migrants in boats, with some accusing it of “scapegoating” migrants for the country’s “broken immigration policy”.

The increasing number of Channel crossings, a heated issue in the UK, is mainly rooted in Brexit, as well as global developments such as increasing conflict, violence and human rights abuses worldwide.

Before Brexit, the UK was part of the European Union’s Dublin Regulation, which allowed it to return some asylum seekers to EU member states without considering their asylum claims.

When the UK left the EU in 2020, it became a country that had to make new return arrangements with any EU member state.

The UK’s new policies on asylum seekers, or the “immigration problem”, came under the spotlight mainly after it announced its Rwanda asylum plan in April last year, formally known as the UK and Rwanda Migration and Economic Development Partnership.

Under then-Prime Minister, Boris Johnson, people who were identified by the UK as being illegal immigrants or asylum seekers would be relocated to Rwanda, which the government claimed was a “fundamentally safe and secure country” for processing, asylum and resettlement.

The plan has been vehemently rejected by many NGOs and international organisations, including UN institutions, as well as politicians.

READ: Asylum seekers in UK win permission to challenge Rwanda plan

One of the points was that, while the number of asylum applications in the UK hit a 20-year high of nearly 75,000 in 2022, it was still well below the EU average, as Germany received more than 240,000 asylum claims last year.

Following controversies, court decisions and criticism, 2023 began with Prime Minister, Rishi Sunak, identifying the issue as one of his five priorities in a January speech, after a record number of more than 45,000 people crossed the English Channel in small boats in 2022, up more than 60 per cent from the previous year.

‘Deeply concerning’ new bill

Two months later, in early March, the British government unveiled the Illegal Migration Bill, its toughest measure yet, aimed at removing migrants entering the country in small boats.

The plan includes detaining people for the first 28 days without bail or judicial review.

The Bill has been met with criticism from human rights organisations and refugee advocates, who argue that it violates international law and the UK’s obligations under the Refugee Convention.

The Bill also triggered mass protests across the UK, with concerned citizens and NGOs accusing the government of scapegoating migrants.

Calling on the government to review the move, “seeking asylum is not a crime” has been one of the slogans chanted at nationwide protests.

The language used in the Bill and its representation of “illegal migrants” has also drawn fierce criticism.

Qirjako Qirko, Albania’s Ambassador to the UK has said that Albanian children in Britain are facing “racist bullying” in schools due to the debate over arrivals by small boats.

The Refugee Council charity said the new Bill “ignores the fundamental point that most of the people in small boats are men, women and children escaping terror and bloodshed from countries.”

READ: Report: Greek authorities stole over $2.1m from refugees, migrants

Another backlash to the Bill, which led to a nearly week-long conflict, came from BBC Sports presenter, Gary Lineker, who said: “This is just an immeasurably cruel policy directed at the most vulnerable people in a language that is not dissimilar to that used by Germany in the 30s.”

A couple of days after the new Bill was announced, Sunak and French President, Emmanuel Macron, met in Paris, the first summit between the two countries in five years.

During the discussions, Altar pledged that the UK will pay France around £476 million ($588 million) over the next three years as part of a deal to curb Channel crossings.

From time to time, France has been blamed for “not fulfilling its moral obligation” in protecting vulnerable people and stopping smugglers from exploiting migrants seeking passage to the UK.

One of the most recent accusations came from the International Organisation for Migration (IOM), which said it is “deeply concerned” by the recently proposed changes to the modern slavery protection system in the UK as part of the new Illegal Migration Bill.

Housing unaccompanied asylum seekers at hotels is also another part of the issue for the UK, where an estimated 51,000 migrants are believed to be staying in 395 hotels at a cost of more than £6 million a day.

In its latest move, the British government, on Wednesday, laid out the details of a plan under which asylum seekers and migrants will be placed in former military barracks, barges and ships, as it tries to cut down on the costs of providing temporary hotel accommodation.

READ: UK apologies for asking Afghan asylum seekers to get documents stamped by Taliban

The following is a timeline of key moments in British asylum policies, agreements and related developments starting from the controversial Rwanda plan.

April 2022:

Rwanda plan was signed by then-UK Home Secretary, Priti Patel, and Rwandan Foreign Minister, Vincent Biruta. The new plan would see asylum seekers trying to enter the UK being sent to Rwanda for resettlement.

June 2022:

Asylum seekers at a detention centre in the UK went on a hunger strike after being told they would be deported to Rwanda.

The UK’s first planned flight was grounded after a last-minute intervention from the European Court of Human Rights.

September 2022:

Rwanda plan was taken to court, with lawyers representing asylum seekers arguing that the British government ignored evidence that the Central African country violates human rights.

October 2022:

Home Secretary, Suella Braverman, described the arrival of asylum seekers on the UK’s southern coast as an “invasion”, drawing a fierce backlash.

November 2022:

The interior ministers of France and the UK signed an agreement to boost police patrols on beaches in northern France to stop people trying to cross the English Channel in small boats.

Investigations revealed that there was an absence of cooperation between French and British authorities and they failed to rescue 27 drowning migrants in November 2021.

December 2022:

After four people died when a migrant boat capsized off south-eastern England, the UK and France vowed to fight human smuggling in the English Channel.

The High Court in London ruled that plans to send asylum seekers to Rwanda while their status is decided are lawful in broad principle.

January 2023:

The top court in London granted an appeal to a charity which challenged the December ruling.

March 2023:

The UK government introduced an illegal migration bill that would allow for the detention and swift removal of anyone who enters the UK illegally.

In a meeting with Macron in Paris, Sunak said the UK will pay France around £476 million ($588 million) over the next three years to help tackle Channel crossings.

During a trip to Rwanda, British Home Secretary Braverman took part in laying the foundation stone for the construction of 500 housing units that will accommodate migrants deported from the UK.

READ: ‘We must stop the boats,’ UK Home Secretary says ahead of statement on new Bill

The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Monitor.