Portuguese / Spanish / English

Is it time to play politics with Hamas?

Hamas political chief Ismail Haniyeh makes a speech during the 12th conference on Jerusalem entitled, "The Vanguards of Jerusalem hold its Sword," in Istanbul, Turkey on 2 December 2021. [Ömer Ensar - Anadolu Agency]
Hamas political chief Ismail Haniyeh in Istanbul, Turkey on 2 December 2021 [Ömer Ensar/Anadolu Agency]

The phone call between Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov and Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh comes amid clashes in Jerusalem. It also occurred in the context of multiple international contacts with the movement, seeking to contain escalation in the occupied Palestinian territories, especially at Al-Aqsa Mosque, following Israeli attempts to storm it on Passover festival (Pesach), a major Jewish holiday.

Russian contacts with Hamas have continued over many years and at different levels, as leaders of the movement have previously visited Moscow several times and met with Russian officials. However, this time, Lavrov's call can be placed in a different context – a context of Russian-Israeli relations deterioration.

It seems that the tension between Moscow and Tel Aviv has reflected positively on the Russian relations with the Palestinian side, as, a few days ago, Russian President Vladimir Putin called Palestinian Authority (PA) President Mahmoud Abbas and showed support for the Palestinians. Regardless of the content of the call, the timing is most significant.

It must be admitted that the Russians have been dealing with the Palestinian issue more rationally and realistically than their European and US counterparts. For several decades, the US and Europe pursued a futile policy in dealing with this complex issue based on isolating the influential Palestinian forces on the ground. They tried to subdue and domesticate them, forcing them to abandon the demands and dreams of their people, as they did with the Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO) and then the PA. They made these forces identify with the Israeli occupation, transforming them into an additional tool of repression against the Palestinian people in the hands of the Israeli occupation, ending up with practically no Palestinian side with whom to negotiate.

READ: PA condemn US removal of Kahane group from terror list

The US and Europe are still playing the same security game with Hamas and the rest of the Palestinian resistance organisations, including the political wing, by placing them on the lists of terrorists, criminalising communication with them and cutting off political and diplomatic channels of communication. At the same time, "Western" governments submitted to a reality imposed by Hamas with blood and fire and found no escape from reaching out through back door channels, thinking that, by not having direct contact with Hamas, they would be depriving it of legitimacy. However, they forget that this movement gained legitimacy through the Palestinian people, not through foreign recognition.

Hamas does not only fire rockets. It has been effectively managing the two million people in the Gaza Strip, despite the 16-year Israeli siege and four wars. This includes functioning government offices, schools, universities, healthcare services, media, places of worship, police, coast guards, courts, banks and recreational facilities. It has good command over the land and people and is successful in applying law and order within its territories. It has demonstrated a high level of professionalism in dealing with the COVID-19 pandemic and the economy. Politically, it maintains warm relations with most Palestinian factions and has relatively good relations with most Arab countries, especially Egypt, Jordan and Lebanon.

Therefore, whenever matters are about to slip out of their hands and the entire region is on the verge of instability, Europe and the US take the initiative to communicate with Hamas through mediators to remedy matters. Unfortunately, they do not find the courage to say "enough is enough" about this futile security policy that has produced nothing but tragedy for all. The time has come for a new, more effective and realistic policy based on recognising the other, even if it is an enemy, and desisting from ignoring the facts on the ground.

READ: Fatah pays election price for PA's mistakes, says official

The recent report by the International Crisis Group represents a serious attempt in this direction in terms of its call for Western countries to abandon the Quartet's conditions, which include the demand for Hamas to recognise Israel, renounce violence and accept all agreements concluded by the PLO and the PA with Israel. This would allow the movement, at least, to participate in a Palestinian national unity government and go for a realistic policy that adopts greater involvement of international powers in the conflict. It would also allow for a more reasonable position in dealing with the Palestinian issue and confronting the illegal Israeli government measures that seek to buy time to change the status quo and make the two-state solution impossible. They should put pressure to reach a long-term armistice in the Gaza Strip, return to the legal status of Al-Aqsa Mosque, stop eviction orders and house demolitions in Jerusalem and the West Bank and halt settlement expansion.

Unless the major players stop the game of denial and accept, in practice, not only in words, that there are, in fact, a Palestinian people who deserve to decide their own future and have their own independent state on the soil of their ancestors, the conflict will continue increasing in frequency and magnitude, until it destabilises and burns places far away from Palestine.

Finding solutions that will, in the end, get out of the cycle of violence instead of waiting for the region to explode at every turn.

The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Monitor.

ArticleAsia & AmericasEurope & RussiaIsraelMiddle EastOpinionPalestineRussiaUS
Show Comments
Order your copy of our latest book - Engaging the World: The Making of Hamas's Foreign Policy - Palestine
Show Comments