Creating new perspectives since 2009

Biden sidesteps public dispute with Netanyahu, despite US concerns

March 28, 2023 at 10:32 pm

US President Joe Biden (L) and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu [DEBBIE HILL/AFP/Getty Images]

Despite tensions between them, President Joe Biden has, so far, avoided an acrimonious public confrontation with Israeli Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, while trying to make clear he opposes a judicial overhaul that has shaken the close US ally, Reuters reports.

In the last three months, Biden and senior members of his team have expressed alarm about Israeli plans for settlement expansion on the West Bank and about violence between Israelis and Palestinians.

Most troubling for the White House, however, was Netanyahu’s plan to reshape the Israeli judiciary system to give the government greater control over appointments to the Supreme Court. The decision propelled Israel into a national crisis with massive protests that forced Netanyahu to delay the move on Monday.

Biden, who has known Netanyahu for about 40 years, has been direct with him in private phone calls, aides say, while publicly expressing support for Israel, the strongest US ally in the Middle East.

READ: Israel Netanyahu buys time, but is still in a fix

“The main operating premise toward this Israeli government is to avoid, whenever and wherever they can, any sustained public confrontation with Netanyahu,” said Aaron David Miller, a Middle East analyst at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace think tank.

“They don’t want a fight. It’s bad politics and its bad policy. It’s messy and awkward,” he said.

US administrations have long been wary of criticising Israel, in part due to the power of pro-Israel lobby groups in Washington, its role as a close ally and the support the country enjoys among ordinary Americans.

The US population largely has favourable views of Israel, home of major religious sites for Christians, Jews and Muslims.

A Gallup poll earlier this month showed that consistent with prior years, Americans view Israel much more favourably than they do the Palestinian Authority, 68 per cent versus 26 per cent.

Emblematic of the Biden approach was a White House statement issued on Sunday night urging “Israeli leaders to find a compromise as soon as possible” as the protests there grew.

“We haven’t taken a hands-off approach,” said a senior administration official. “We understand that there’s a domestic political process that’s playing out. So we’ve been very clear that we have concerns over this reform legislation and we’ve also said very clearly that we want there to be a compromise found. So we’re watching this very closely.”

Dennis Ross, a veteran US peace negotiator between Israelis and Arabs, said the Biden administration had expressed its misgivings about Israel’s judicial proposals but had done so privately, where possible.

Ross, who is now at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy think tank, said he thought that approach of largely making the case in private was the proper one.

Halie Soifer, Executive Director of the Jewish Democratic Council of America, said the way the Biden administration has handled this crisis, thus far, is in keeping with Biden’s commitment to the US-Israel partnership.

“And sometimes friends are most honest with each other behind closed doors, and it appears that that is what is happening here,” she said.

But, keeping a distance from Netanyahu, Biden has yet to invite him to visit the White House since the Israeli began his sixth term as Prime Minister in December.

A senior administration official said on Tuesday there is no plan as of yet for Netanyahu to visit but “Israeli leaders have a long tradition of visiting Washington, and Prime Minister Netanyahu will likely visit at some point.”

On the other hand, there have been no administration threats to limit US funding to Israel which, according to a 1 March Congressional Research Service report, is the largest cumulative recipient of US foreign assistance since World War II.

There is historically little appetite in the US Congress to take such a step and the United States depends on Israel in a region where Western concerns about Iran have been growing.

READ: Netanyahu to be invited to White House after suspending judicial reform